AutosTalk Forums  

To buy new or to build?

4x4 Chevy/GMC Trucks 4x4 Chevy/GMC Trucks Discussions (alt.autos.4x4.chevy-trucks)


Discuss To buy new or to build? in the 4x4 Chevy/GMC Trucks forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
Rick J.
 
Posts: n/a

Default To buy new or to build? - 08-12-2005 , 07:57 PM






Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I want from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a mild
small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new atlas 4 speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and lots of
other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of money.
The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries more prestige.
I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it or not, prestige
counts with customers.

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
r_d
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-12-2005 , 10:14 PM







"Rick J." <noemailplease (AT) none (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I want
from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a mild
small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new atlas 4
speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and lots of
other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of money.
The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries more prestige.
I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it or not, prestige
counts with customers.
Yea but the other side of the fence, you can show them the quality of the
truck you built and prove to them you actually know how to work with your
hands. Physical proof of ability is much more important then a sales pitch.
Although, as a suggestion you can still get 6.2 or 6.5 diesels in "drop in
packages", and a few months ago the 6.6 (Duramax) was approved for military
use. Therefore, with in the next year the Duramax should be available over
the counter in drop in condition (i.e. complete and ready to run, and I hope
with mechanical injection. I just can't see the military fussing with the
computers). Therefore, you may want to consider going with your build, but
modifying it to a 1ton 4x4 and going with a diesel. Gas engines are easy to
build but with gas going to a soon to be $3+ per gal. a diesel will get you
better mileage (and in most states no emissions inspection). I bet if you
go with a 6.5 and 3.73 axles, you could pull upper teens or low 20's on the
highway. Unfortunately, these days you have to consider how much it will
cost to feed your horse... You tell yourself well it does not matter, I can
tolerate 14mpg until you realize that totals to (in my case) $1200 per year
in gasoline at $2.35 gas and with it at $3 I will be looking at $1500 or
more. Therefore, look to the future, in the end the extra mileage will
return the extra cost of the drive train with in a few years. ...My opinion
for what it is worth...


good luck,
mark




Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Charles Bendig
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-12-2005 , 10:55 PM



Rick J. wrote:
Quote:
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I want from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a mild
small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new atlas 4 speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and lots of
other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of money.
The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries more prestige.
I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it or not, prestige
counts with customers.

If you can afford it, go for both. I would. Use the New truck for work,
the other for play. You can find Clean K-10's or K-20's on Ebay in
Texas, Kansus, Florida, Gorgia, and a few other states. A K-30 uses a
larger frame. 8 inch for the K-10 & K-20, 10 Inch on the K-30.
Personially I would start with a K-30. With Dynatrack Pro-Rock Dana60's
with the High pinion gears. This will reduce driveline angle.

Really if you want to do it a bit at a time, ordering parts maybe a
month a head (so they come in just as your ready), you could build one
hell of a K-30 over a year or two.
Charles


Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old   
Paul in Redland
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-12-2005 , 10:59 PM



Myself, I'd buy the new truck with the D-Max and the Allison tranny. I've
heard that the Allison will be a 6 speed for '06. Nix on the manual tranny,
GM is still having clutch problems. The Allison is a better transmission
anyway, drive one, you'll see. Of course, that's what I'd do. If you have
lots of free time ( no kids, a wife that understands these things, etc ),
the necessary tools, a shop to work in and are willing to end up with a
neat 20 year old truck that you built yourself go that route. Bear in mind
that a truck that one builds themselves piecemeal like you speak of will
probably never be quite right, and you'll constantly be working on it (
unless your skills and expertise at such things are professional quality.
Then there is the 'prestige' issue. Hands down, get the new truck. Put
yourself in your customer's shoes. A new truck projects success which comes
from a well run business. On the other hand, a 20 year old truck, even a
nice one, projects an image of either a guy that is just making ends meet
( his business is struggling ), or a kid that is not quite a businessman
yet. These are all my opinions, but then that's what you asked for.
Oh........did I mention, I bought a new D-max 2 years ago. My 5th or 6th
pickup, but my first diesel. I'll never buy another gas truck or one with a
manual transmission again. The diesels will out perform the gassers any day
of the week and if you 'chip' them you can get 450 hp and over 900 lb-ft of
torque.
Hope this helps,
Paul




"Rick J." <noemailplease (AT) none (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I want
from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a mild
small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new atlas 4
speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and lots of
other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of money.
The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries more prestige.
I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it or not, prestige
counts with customers.



Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old   
Adam Frazier
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 05:24 AM



I wish that was the only problem I had to worry about in life, weather to
build a truck or buy one.

"r_d" <rock_doctor (AT) nospam (DOT) hotmail.com> wrote

Quote:
"Rick J." <noemailplease (AT) none (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:hHaLe.212$5U2.43 (AT) lakeread07 (DOT) ..
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I want
from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a mild
small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new atlas 4
speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and lots
of
other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of
money.
The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries more
prestige.
I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it or not, prestige
counts with customers.

Yea but the other side of the fence, you can show them the quality of the
truck you built and prove to them you actually know how to work with your
hands. Physical proof of ability is much more important then a sales
pitch.
Although, as a suggestion you can still get 6.2 or 6.5 diesels in "drop in
packages", and a few months ago the 6.6 (Duramax) was approved for
military
use. Therefore, with in the next year the Duramax should be available
over
the counter in drop in condition (i.e. complete and ready to run, and I
hope
with mechanical injection. I just can't see the military fussing with the
computers). Therefore, you may want to consider going with your build,
but
modifying it to a 1ton 4x4 and going with a diesel. Gas engines are easy
to
build but with gas going to a soon to be $3+ per gal. a diesel will get
you
better mileage (and in most states no emissions inspection). I bet if you
go with a 6.5 and 3.73 axles, you could pull upper teens or low 20's on
the
highway. Unfortunately, these days you have to consider how much it will
cost to feed your horse... You tell yourself well it does not matter, I
can
tolerate 14mpg until you realize that totals to (in my case) $1200 per
year
in gasoline at $2.35 gas and with it at $3 I will be looking at $1500 or
more. Therefore, look to the future, in the end the extra mileage will
return the extra cost of the drive train with in a few years. ...My
opinion
for what it is worth...


good luck,
mark





Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old   
mudmonkey
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 06:46 PM



the argurment can go both ways, build a good truck that suits your
company's needs looks good, but dont forget about the appearance a new
truck provides. Me I would prefer function over form, so I would lean
towards the built for the task truck. What would you be doing mostly
with the truck, hauling the cargo or doing administative work?


Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old   
Rick J.
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 11:24 PM



Charles Bendig <rarepartshunter (AT) yahoo (DOT) com> wrote in
news:ZidLe.57795$B52.6425 (AT) tornado (DOT) ohiordc.rr.com:

Quote:
Rick J. wrote:
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I
want from an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a
mild small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new
atlas 4 speed transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air
lockers and lots of other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of
money. The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries
more prestige. I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it
or not, prestige counts with customers.


If you can afford it, go for both.
I can't afford both.

Quote:
I would. Use the New truck for
work,
the other for play. You can find Clean K-10's or K-20's on Ebay in
Texas, Kansus, Florida, Gorgia, and a few other states. A K-30 uses a
larger frame. 8 inch for the K-10 & K-20, 10 Inch on the K-30.
Personially I would start with a K-30.
I thought the reg cab k30 (non c+c) and k20 had the same frame and the
K10 was the one that was different (smaller).



Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old   
Rick J.
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 11:26 PM



"r_d" <rock_doctor (AT) nospam (DOT) hotmail.com> wrote in
news:42fd577e$0$50899$ec3e2dad (AT) news (DOT) usenetmonster.com:

Quote:
"Rick J." <noemailplease (AT) none (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:hHaLe.212$5U2.43 (AT) lakeread07 (DOT) ..
Been thinking about whether to buy a new truck or to build what I
want from
an older truck. If I buy new it would be:

3500, reg cab, srw, duramax diesel, six speed, 4wd

If I go the build-it route, it will start with an 82 to 87 K20, a
mild small block, an nv4500 or maybe a richmond six speed, the new
atlas 4 speed
transfer case, dynatrac axles front and rear with air lockers and
lots of other goodies.

To build the truck from scratch takes lots of time and quite a bit of
money. Buying a new truck takes a small amount of time but lots of
money. The build it truck will be more fun. The new truck carries
more prestige. I'm in the construction business so, whether I like it
or not, prestige counts with customers.

Yea but the other side of the fence, you can show them the quality of
the truck you built and prove to them you actually know how to work
with your hands. Physical proof of ability is much more important
then a sales pitch.
Agreed, but my skills are in building houses, not trucks.

Quote:
Although, as a suggestion you can still get 6.2 or
6.5 diesels in "drop in packages", and a few months ago the 6.6
(Duramax) was approved for military use. Therefore, with in the next
year the Duramax should be available over the counter in drop in
condition (i.e. complete and ready to run, and I hope with mechanical
injection. I just can't see the military fussing with the computers).
Therefore, you may want to consider going with your build, but
modifying it to a 1ton 4x4 and going with a diesel. Gas engines are
easy to build but with gas going to a soon to be $3+ per gal. a diesel
will get you better mileage (and in most states no emissions
inspection). I bet if you go with a 6.5 and 3.73 axles, you could
pull upper teens or low 20's on the highway. Unfortunately, these
days you have to consider how much it will cost to feed your horse...
You tell yourself well it does not matter, I can tolerate 14mpg until
you realize that totals to (in my case) $1200 per year in gasoline at
$2.35 gas and with it at $3 I will be looking at $1500 or more.
Therefore, look to the future, in the end the extra mileage will
return the extra cost of the drive train with in a few years. ...My
opinion for what it is worth...
Those are good points, thanks.


Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old   
Rick J.
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 11:30 PM



"mudmonkey" <MatandLaura (AT) gmail (DOT) com> wrote in news:1123973179.596547.248490
@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com:

Quote:
the argurment can go both ways, build a good truck that suits your
company's needs looks good, but dont forget about the appearance a new
truck provides. Me I would prefer function over form, so I would lean
towards the built for the task truck. What would you be doing mostly
with the truck, hauling the cargo or doing administative work?
Hauling tools and material. But when you price jobs they see what you're
driving. I don't know how much it matters, but I'm pretty sure it does
matter to some people.


Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old   
Rick J.
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Re: To buy new or to build? - 08-13-2005 , 11:56 PM



SnoMan <UseLinkToEmail (AT) AutoForumz (DOT) com> wrote
Quote:
Not me the, Dmax truck and chaasis is not half the truck a built up 82
to 87 would be hands down. Those old trucks were tuff and you could
easily add a D60 to the front of one for big rubber and the diesel
engine adds about 500 lbs to front of truck and why in the world would
you want to add weight to the front of a off road truck (kinda like
off roading with the weight of a snow plow up there) with a very
limited RPM range when you could trick out a "RAT" motor and get HP
and a RPM range to "clean the tires" that diesel owners can only
dream off. A good offroad truck needs power over a wide RPM range,
not just a 1000 RPMs or so. Also I hate that damn brush, stump and
rock catcher cross member that GM put below the frame rails with the
Silverados.
My first truck was a 68 utility body with a 327 and a sm420 and 4.56
gears. God I loved that truck. It had plenty of power for me and was
extremely simple to work on. It had smallish stock tires and the engine
screamed on the highway, but it was a fun truck to drive and own.

The biggest downer, imo, with new trucks today is that they are too
complicated. I don't need or want half the stuff I'm forced to buy. The
35Gs for a new truck reflects that complexity. I could probably build
what I want with a third of that money.





Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.