AutosTalk Forums  

Corsa diesel starter motor EEEEEK sound

Cars Maintenance General car maintenance (uk.rec.cars.maintenance)


Discuss Corsa diesel starter motor EEEEEK sound in the Cars Maintenance forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
jayseeblue
 
Posts: n/a

Default Corsa diesel starter motor EEEEEK sound - 07-13-2009 , 03:23 AM






Hi

I couple of months ago I posted about an intermitent problem with my
1996 Corsa diesel starter. Well I replaced the starter and solenoid
with a second hand one off an old diesel Corsa I owned which had no
problems when it was on that previous car. The "new" starter was off a
1.7 diesel and I fitted it to a 1.5td.....Both Isuzu engines.

The two starters look the same but have a different arrangement for
the solenoid and also when you look at the cog that comes out,
although it's the same size it looks slightly different.

My problem is that it starts fine but at the point of firing there is
a more-than-audible EEEEEK sound!!!!! For about half a second. It
hasn't got any worse in a month of driving.

To get this starter on I had to take the solenoid off first then put
it on with the starter in situ and it is very difficult to put the
solenoid rod over the starter rod. I guess I must've done that bit ok
otherwise it simply wouldn't work???

So, maybe these Isuzu starters are not as generic as I've been told???
I would be very grateful if someone could hazard a guess as to what's
causing this annoying noise as I'm going to sell the car and don't
want to turn the stereo up while I start it!!!

Thanks to any replies

Jon

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Conor
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Corsa diesel starter motor EEEEEK sound - 07-13-2009 , 04:00 AM






In article <ec6dde31-c6b8-4fc4-817b-0dc7e6a72672
@k20g2000vbp.googlegroups.com>, jayseeblue says...
Quote:
Hi

I couple of months ago I posted about an intermitent problem with my
1996 Corsa diesel starter. Well I replaced the starter and solenoid
with a second hand one off an old diesel Corsa I owned which had no
problems when it was on that previous car. The "new" starter was off a
1.7 diesel and I fitted it to a 1.5td.....Both Isuzu engines.

The two starters look the same but have a different arrangement for
the solenoid and also when you look at the cog that comes out,
although it's the same size it looks slightly different.

My problem is that it starts fine but at the point of firing there is
a more-than-audible EEEEEK sound!!!!! For about half a second. It
hasn't got any worse in a month of driving.

To get this starter on I had to take the solenoid off first then put
it on with the starter in situ and it is very difficult to put the
solenoid rod over the starter rod. I guess I must've done that bit ok
otherwise it simply wouldn't work???

So, maybe these Isuzu starters are not as generic as I've been told???
I would be very grateful if someone could hazard a guess as to what's
causing this annoying noise as I'm going to sell the car and don't
want to turn the stereo up while I start it!!!

Thanks to any replies

Jon
Instead of pissing about with second hand shite that's not even from
the same engine, why not just go get a reconditioned one?

--
Conor
www.notebooks-r-us.co.uk
I only please one person per day. Today is not your day. Tomorrow isn't
looking good either. - Scott Adams

Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Mrcheerful
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Corsa diesel starter motor EEEEEK sound - 07-13-2009 , 05:03 AM



jayseeblue wrote:
Quote:
Hi

I couple of months ago I posted about an intermitent problem with my
1996 Corsa diesel starter. Well I replaced the starter and solenoid
with a second hand one off an old diesel Corsa I owned which had no
problems when it was on that previous car. The "new" starter was off a
1.7 diesel and I fitted it to a 1.5td.....Both Isuzu engines.

The two starters look the same but have a different arrangement for
the solenoid and also when you look at the cog that comes out,
although it's the same size it looks slightly different.

My problem is that it starts fine but at the point of firing there is
a more-than-audible EEEEEK sound!!!!! For about half a second. It
hasn't got any worse in a month of driving.

To get this starter on I had to take the solenoid off first then put
it on with the starter in situ and it is very difficult to put the
solenoid rod over the starter rod. I guess I must've done that bit ok
otherwise it simply wouldn't work???

So, maybe these Isuzu starters are not as generic as I've been told???
I would be very grateful if someone could hazard a guess as to what's
causing this annoying noise as I'm going to sell the car and don't
want to turn the stereo up while I start it!!!

Thanks to any replies

Jon
likely that the teeth are still left touching the edge of the ring gear for
a little while. take the starter out and inspect it, the fault will be
obvious, grind away the very end of the teeth so they no longer touch, just
a millimeter or two will probably do.

Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.