AutosTalk Forums  

On the Diesel V Petrol debate...

Cars Modifications Aspects of car modifications (tuning, styling) (uk.rec.cars.modifications)


Discuss On the Diesel V Petrol debate... in the Cars Modifications forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #11  
Old   
Depresion
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 09:41 AM







"MeatballTurbo" <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote in message >
Quote:
I was thinking more along the diesel supercar that you could afford to
run type thing. Maybe even an NA W12 from a Taureg/Phaeton
Hmm I bet you could get more than 400bhp out of the 5L V10 TDi the standard
313PS can't be the best the engine can do. Having had a quick look superchips
will take it up to 356bhp & 855Nm. About the same bhp as a Chevrolet V8 5.7L V8
H.O. but twice the torque.




Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old   
Dan405
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 09:46 AM






"AstraVanMan" <FuckOff (AT) WithThanks (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
But if you turbo'd and fitted the same size petrol engine, it would be
better.

Define better (have we been here before? :-)

Peter


More powerful, with as much if not more torque. You're building an insane
track car here remember, diesel has no benefit.

--
Dan
http://www.danontherun.com




Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old   
scott
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 10:11 AM



MeatballTurbo wrote:
Quote:
In article <zO3kc.45$n3.22 (AT) newsfe2-gui (DOT) server.ntli.net>,
finlayson1nospam (AT) ntlworld (DOT) com says...

"MeatballTurbo" <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:MPG.1afad3a6a7364aa998a109 (AT) news (DOT) individual.net...
I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8 (something from a
greyhound bus like they use in monster trucks)

Mid mount it in a nice spaceframe chassis (Something a little bigger
than a lotus elise/VX220) and give it the turbo/supercharger
combination to maximise torque all through the rev range.

I bet it could do some wonderful things.


stop giving me ideas here

theres already been a perkins derv powered E30


I'm thinking 6->8 litres running in a chassis weighing arround 750-
800kgs (reliant robin weight).
What is the power to weight ratio of a 6 litre diesel engine? How does it
compare to a good small petrol engine? (like the one used in the caterham
r500)?

Quote:
Bit like the guy who built the rover V8 powered reliant pro-street
kitten.

But build it from scratch to looky sporty and handle well.
"Sporty", "handle well", you're going to have a huge monster with an 8 litre
engine in it!!!




Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old   
Depresion
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 10:12 AM




"Steve Firth" <usenet-urcm (AT) malloc (DOT) co.uk> wrote

Quote:
MeatballTurbo <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote:

I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8

Oh why not got he whole hog and get one of the Gardner diesels that were
fitted to Hunter/Killer subs? A straight sixteen with a supercharger
with a manual clutch.
What sort of MPG did they get?




Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old   
MeatballTurbo
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 10:17 AM



In article <js8kc.117$xt3.98 (AT) newsfe1-gui (DOT) server.ntli.net>, blank@
128.0.0.1 says...
Quote:
"MeatballTurbo" <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote in message

I was thinking more along the diesel supercar that you could afford to
run type thing. Maybe even an NA W12 from a Taureg/Phaeton

Hmm I bet you could get more than 400bhp out of the 5L V10 TDi the standard
313PS can't be the best the engine can do. Having had a quick look superchips
will take it up to 356bhp & 855Nm. About the same bhp as a Chevrolet V8 5.7L V8
H.O. but twice the torque.



Now we are thinking. V10 is good.
--
The poster formerly known as Skodapilot.
http://www.bouncing-czechs.com


Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old   
MeatballTurbo
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 10:36 AM



In article <1gd0hzu.1335hsgwdm1n7N%%steve%@malloc.co.uk>, usenet-
urcm (AT) malloc (DOT) co.uk says...
Quote:
MeatballTurbo <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote:

I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8

Oh why not got he whole hog and get one of the Gardner diesels that were
fitted to Hunter/Killer subs? A straight sixteen with a supercharger
with a manual clutch.


One of your better ideas
--
The poster formerly known as Skodapilot.
http://www.bouncing-czechs.com


Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old   
MeatballTurbo
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 10:38 AM



In article <c6r5vn$1la8$1 (AT) news (DOT) f.de.plusline.net>, scott (AT) spam (DOT) com
says...
Quote:
MeatballTurbo wrote:
In article <zO3kc.45$n3.22 (AT) newsfe2-gui (DOT) server.ntli.net>,
finlayson1nospam (AT) ntlworld (DOT) com says...

"MeatballTurbo" <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:MPG.1afad3a6a7364aa998a109 (AT) news (DOT) individual.net...
I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8 (something from a
greyhound bus like they use in monster trucks)

Mid mount it in a nice spaceframe chassis (Something a little bigger
than a lotus elise/VX220) and give it the turbo/supercharger
combination to maximise torque all through the rev range.

I bet it could do some wonderful things.


stop giving me ideas here

theres already been a perkins derv powered E30


I'm thinking 6->8 litres running in a chassis weighing arround 750-
800kgs (reliant robin weight).

What is the power to weight ratio of a 6 litre diesel engine? How does it
compare to a good small petrol engine? (like the one used in the caterham
r500)?

Bit like the guy who built the rover V8 powered reliant pro-street
kitten.

But build it from scratch to looky sporty and handle well.

"Sporty", "handle well", you're going to have a huge monster with an 8 litre
engine in it!!!



Arround the middle of the car.
if you design and build the car to take that sort of weight from the
start, you can make the suspension work surprisingly well, have brakes
that would haul it down, and have it handle too.
--
The poster formerly known as Skodapilot.
http://www.bouncing-czechs.com


Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old   
scott
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 11:22 AM



MeatballTurbo wrote:
Quote:
In article <c6r5vn$1la8$1 (AT) news (DOT) f.de.plusline.net>, scott (AT) spam (DOT) com
says...
MeatballTurbo wrote:
In article <zO3kc.45$n3.22 (AT) newsfe2-gui (DOT) server.ntli.net>,
finlayson1nospam (AT) ntlworld (DOT) com says...

"MeatballTurbo" <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:MPG.1afad3a6a7364aa998a109 (AT) news (DOT) individual.net...
I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8 (something
from a greyhound bus like they use in monster trucks)

Mid mount it in a nice spaceframe chassis (Something a little
bigger than a lotus elise/VX220) and give it the turbo/supercharger
combination to maximise torque all through the rev range.

I bet it could do some wonderful things.


stop giving me ideas here

theres already been a perkins derv powered E30


I'm thinking 6->8 litres running in a chassis weighing arround 750-
800kgs (reliant robin weight).

What is the power to weight ratio of a 6 litre diesel engine? How
does it compare to a good small petrol engine? (like the one used in
the caterham r500)?

Bit like the guy who built the rover V8 powered reliant pro-street
kitten.

But build it from scratch to looky sporty and handle well.

"Sporty", "handle well", you're going to have a huge monster with an
8 litre engine in it!!!



Arround the middle of the car.
if you design and build the car to take that sort of weight from the
start, you can make the suspension work surprisingly well, have brakes
that would haul it down, and have it handle too.
Hmmm, lighter cars always seem to stop quicker than heavier cars, surely
most heavy cars are designed to be heavy from the start? Is it not
something to do with the tyres? I think the coefficient of friction
decreases as the vertical load increases??? Would the same reasoning mean
that you wouldn't be able to corner as fast?




Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old   
Pete M
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 12:18 PM



In news:MPG.1afad3a6a7364aa998a109 (AT) news (DOT) individual.net,
MeatballTurbo <carl.robson (AT) bouncing-czechs (DOT) com> decided to enlighten our
sheltered souls with a rant as follows
Quote:
I would seriously love to find a nice big Diesel V8 (something from a
greyhound bus like they use in monster trucks)

Mid mount it in a nice spaceframe chassis (Something a little bigger
than a lotus elise/VX220) and give it the turbo/supercharger
combination to maximise torque all through the rev range.

I bet it could do some wonderful things.
What ya want is the 6.8 V10 petrol out of a Ford Excursion... not exactly
frugal, but it's capable of almost 16 mpg on a run whilst dragging about 4
tonne about.. It's also *VERY* fucking grunty, very smooth, and I think it's
all alloy


--
Pete M

Ford Capri !!!
Mercedes 500 SEL,


Scouse Git extraordinaire.
Liverpool, Great Britain




Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old   
Tim S Kemp
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: On the Diesel V Petrol debate... - 04-29-2004 , 01:08 PM



xMeatballTurbo wrote:
Quote:
In article <n76kc.1073$D4.870@newsfe6-win>, FuckOff (AT) WithThanks (DOT) com
says...
But if you turbo'd and fitted the same size petrol engine, it would
be better.

Define better (have we been here before? :-)

Peter



That was the whole point.

I reckon with low down grunt, and a pretty good top end, it would
make a excellent trackday motor.
So turbo a petrol motor.....




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.