AutosTalk Forums  

OT? : New car suggestions

Cars Modifications Aspects of car modifications (tuning, styling) (uk.rec.cars.modifications)


Discuss OT? : New car suggestions in the Cars Modifications forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #71  
Old   
Nom
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-16-2004 , 05:42 AM






"Carl Gibbs" <cagmeister (AT) yahoo (DOT) co.uk> wrote

Quote:
"Jamesy" <beats (AT) rootmeanSORRYSPAMSOFFsquared (DOT) co.uk> wrote in message
news:734a202fa4491eaa7e7cb83bb29f862f (AT) news (DOT) teranews.com...

snip

Yep - all old cars are spectacularly unsafe in comparison with their
modern
counterparts. It's only the last few years that schemes like NCAP have
been
taken seriously.

One more reason to discount old cars then

*cough* except Volvos *cough*

What about some of the old Saabs with built in roll cages? They were
incredibly strong...
....so you totally die in any impact !

Crumple-zones are what save your life - if the car is totally rigid, you're
screwed




Reply With Quote
  #72  
Old   
Douglas Payne
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-16-2004 , 06:14 PM







"Nom" <Nom (AT) Somewhere (DOT) Somewhere> wrote


Quote:
What about some of the old Saabs with built in roll cages? They were
incredibly strong...

...so you totally die in any impact !

Crumple-zones are what save your life - if the car is totally rigid,
you're
screwed
I think you'd find it pretty hard to build a rollcage that didnt deform to
some extent in a crash.

F1 cars are mega strong, but rediculously safe compared to road cars because
head on, they deform at a rate where the human body can still survive, its
something like 30g over a fraction of a second (I'm not exactly sure).
Pretty impressive when they can easily be travelling at over 150mph. I'll
bet good money it beats the shit out of a 600Ti (c:, or indeed pretty much
anything on the public road.

Daresay you'd need a proper harness and some sort of neck protection like
the F1 dudes use to have much chance of surviving that kind of impact
though.

Douglas




Reply With Quote
  #73  
Old   
Nom
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-17-2004 , 04:06 AM



Douglas Payne wrote:
Quote:
"Nom" <Nom (AT) Somewhere (DOT) Somewhere> wrote in message
news:c0q6p5029du (AT) enews4 (DOT) newsguy.com...

What about some of the old Saabs with built in roll cages? They
were incredibly strong...

...so you totally die in any impact !

Crumple-zones are what save your life - if the car is totally rigid,
you're screwed

I think you'd find it pretty hard to build a rollcage that didnt
deform to some extent in a crash.

F1 cars are mega strong, but rediculously safe compared to road cars
because head on, they deform at a rate where the human body can still
survive, its something like 30g over a fraction of a second (I'm not
exactly sure). Pretty impressive when they can easily be travelling
at over 150mph. I'll bet good money it beats the shit out of a 600Ti
(c:, or indeed pretty much anything on the public road.
The next part of your post sums up nicely :

Quote:
Daresay you'd need a proper harness and some sort of neck protection
like the F1 dudes use to have much chance of surviving that kind of
impact though.
Spot on.
WRC cars are very rigid (compared to a road car at least), but the drivers
are stuck in with a four point harness, and wearing a helment and stuff. If
you tried the same with a normal car seatbelt, you'd, er, die.






Reply With Quote
  #74  
Old   
Douglas Payne
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-17-2004 , 06:49 AM




"Nom" <Nom (AT) Somewhere (DOT) Somewhere> wrote

Quote:
Douglas Payne wrote:
"Nom" <Nom (AT) Somewhere (DOT) Somewhere> wrote in message
news:c0q6p5029du (AT) enews4 (DOT) newsguy.com...

What about some of the old Saabs with built in roll cages? They
were incredibly strong...

...so you totally die in any impact !

Crumple-zones are what save your life - if the car is totally rigid,
you're screwed

I think you'd find it pretty hard to build a rollcage that didnt
deform to some extent in a crash.

F1 cars are mega strong, but rediculously safe compared to road cars
because head on, they deform at a rate where the human body can still
survive, its something like 30g over a fraction of a second (I'm not
exactly sure). Pretty impressive when they can easily be travelling
at over 150mph. I'll bet good money it beats the shit out of a 600Ti
(c:, or indeed pretty much anything on the public road.

The next part of your post sums up nicely :

Daresay you'd need a proper harness and some sort of neck protection
like the F1 dudes use to have much chance of surviving that kind of
impact though.

Spot on.
WRC cars are very rigid (compared to a road car at least), but the drivers
are stuck in with a four point harness, and wearing a helment and stuff.
If
you tried the same with a normal car seatbelt, you'd, er, die.
What I think I was saying was, I'd rather have a fairly solid car than a
soft one if I was going to have a high speed impact. Well, a nice long soft
car at least. My Carlton probably fits the bill here, although I hope I
never find out.

Douglas




Reply With Quote
  #75  
Old   
Doki
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-19-2004 , 09:16 AM




Nom <Nom (AT) Somewhere (DOT) Somewhere> wrote

Quote:
Douglas Payne wrote:

Daresay you'd need a proper harness and some sort of neck protection
like the F1 dudes use to have much chance of surviving that kind of
impact though.

Spot on.
WRC cars are very rigid (compared to a road car at least), but the drivers
are stuck in with a four point harness, and wearing a helment and stuff.
If
you tried the same with a normal car seatbelt, you'd, er, die.
Anyone remember the documentary about the Americans experimenting with
rocket sleds in the 50s / 60s? A bloke worked out you can survive absolutely
massive G forces as long as you're strapped in tightly and they don't go on
for very long. With a 3 point seatbelt you've got plenty of room to flap
about and die, and the car isn't rigid enough to slow you down that quickly.




Reply With Quote
  #76  
Old   
Nom
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-23-2004 , 05:36 AM



Doki wrote:
Quote:
Anyone remember the documentary about the Americans experimenting with
rocket sleds in the 50s / 60s? A bloke worked out you can survive
absolutely massive G forces as long as you're strapped in tightly and
they don't go on for very long. With a 3 point seatbelt you've got
plenty of room to flap about and die, and the car isn't rigid enough
to slow you down that quickly.
That's not really relevent though, cos you have to be strapped in 100%
tightly

How would you turn the steering wheel, or press the pedals ?




Reply With Quote
  #77  
Old   
Albert T Cone
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: New car suggestions - 02-23-2004 , 10:25 AM



Quote:
Anyone remember the documentary about the Americans experimenting with
rocket sleds in the 50s / 60s? A bloke worked out you can survive
absolutely massive G forces as long as you're strapped in tightly and
they don't go on for very long.

That's not really relevent though, cos you have to be strapped in 100%
tightly

How would you turn the steering wheel, or press the pedals ?


Trained hamsters and a whistle.


Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.