AutosTalk Forums  

window motor

General Motors Discussions About General Motors vehicles (alt.autos.gm)


Discuss window motor in the General Motors forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #11  
Old   
tom
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-20-2007 , 07:54 AM






scott wrote:
Quote:
On Mar 19, 7:40 am, <H... (AT) nospam (DOT) nix> wrote:
"Edwin Pawlowski" <e... (AT) snet (DOT) net> wrote in message

news:0%nKh.8015$Um6.965 (AT) newssvr12 (DOT) news.prodigy.net...

Windows are too common a problem on cars. It would take just pennies to
make
them more reliable.
They have been a traditional problem on GM cars, I believe, as the car ages
a bit.

I don't seem to see the same on Fords or Dodges, at least not as severely.

True. You don't see this problem as often on say, Toyotas or Lexus.
They would not tolerate a supplier / design providing a part that was
underdesigned and failed as often as it appears that the GM units have
a habit of doing.

i find it strange the toyota and other jap dealers have service
departments, must be like the maytag men. could save a lot of money.
had my pontiac in for oil change other day service bays had two toyotas,
and a honda, and one buick.


Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old   
80 Knight
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-20-2007 , 08:17 PM






"scott" <scott.snowboard (AT) gmail (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
On Mar 19, 7:40 am, <H... (AT) nospam (DOT) nix> wrote:
"Edwin Pawlowski" <e... (AT) snet (DOT) net> wrote in message

news:0%nKh.8015$Um6.965 (AT) newssvr12 (DOT) news.prodigy.net...


Windows are too common a problem on cars. It would take just pennies to
make
them more reliable.

They have been a traditional problem on GM cars, I believe, as the car
ages
a bit.

I don't seem to see the same on Fords or Dodges, at least not as
severely.

True. You don't see this problem as often on say, Toyotas or Lexus.
They would not tolerate a supplier / design providing a part that was
underdesigned and failed as often as it appears that the GM units have
a habit of doing.
Well, Toyota's are gifts from God Himself, so why would they break down?
Hope you can speak Japanese...




Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old   
scott
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-22-2007 , 05:31 AM



Quote:
Well, Toyota's are gifts from God Himself, so why would they break down?
Hope you can speak Japanese...- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -
Don't get me wrong, I own two Oldsmobiles!

But....I just finished replacing a wiper motor assembly on a 98 GM
van, and the local parts store had the part! This tells me a few
things: A) They are failing enough to stock the part and make money
selling them, and B) On the other hand its good to have parts so
readily available. I also just replaced both front hub/wheel
bearings...but the transmission has not been touched and the vehicle
has 140k on it. Of course I did have to have the intake manifold
gasket replaced, which should have been a recall... Overall its been
good on drivetrain but bad on other things like interior bits,
interior fit and finish, the power door quit working and gave up
trying to diagnose, rear window vents work sometimes, sometimes only
one works, etc. The good part of my GM cars is that I buy used, and
with the poor resale value you can get a great value on a vehicle with
a lot of life left in it.

Scott



Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old   
80 Knight
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-22-2007 , 06:26 AM




"scott" <scott.snowboard (AT) gmail (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
Well, Toyota's are gifts from God Himself, so why would they break down?
Hope you can speak Japanese...- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Don't get me wrong, I own two Oldsmobiles!
Which models, if you don't mind me asking?

Quote:
But....I just finished replacing a wiper motor assembly on a 98 GM
van, and the local parts store had the part! This tells me a few
things: A) They are failing enough to stock the part and make money
selling them, and B) On the other hand its good to have parts so
readily available.
No offence, but if that is your major complaint, then I don't know what to
say. Parts stores are supposed to have the part you want. Are you telling me
if you walked into a Toyota parts store, and they didn't have your part, you
would walk out saying "wow, I'm so glad they didn't have my part, 'cause it
means they don't break down much"?

Quote:
I also just replaced both front hub/wheel
bearings...but the transmission has not been touched and the vehicle
has 140k on it. Of course I did have to have the intake manifold
gasket replaced, which should have been a recall...
That I will agree with. I recently had a gasket job done in an '01 Montana.
$1100 (Canadian) for the repair...Then again, it also has well over
200,000KM's on it.

Quote:
Overall its been
good on drivetrain but bad on other things like interior bits,
interior fit and finish, the power door quit working and gave up
trying to diagnose, rear window vents work sometimes, sometimes only
one works, etc.
I only had those kind of problems on my '91 Grand Prix. The main reason was
I had a tendency to beat the crap out of the car. Either way, not once did I
have any major problems with the door locks or power windows. It did have
several different shades of burgundy though!

Quote:
The good part of my GM cars is that I buy used, and
with the poor resale value you can get a great value on a vehicle with
a lot of life left in it.
It just gives me more reason not to by a Japanese car.




Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old   
scott
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-22-2007 , 01:46 PM




Quote:
- Show quoted text -

Don't get me wrong, I own two Oldsmobiles!

Which models, if you don't mind me asking?

I have a 98 Olds Silo GLS van, extended with about every option
including rear AC, rear audio entertainment, middle row captain
chairs, trac control, auto leveling, leather, etc. Bought used for
$11k which was good deal and we've used it quite a bit and its been a
good vehicle besides the intake gasket.

I also have a '00 Intrigue GLS with the 3.5 short star motor. Its
also loaded and has the PCS stability control system, 4 wheel disks,
leather, bose, dual climate, sunroof, chrome wheels, etc. I got that
on Ebay for $5k with 90k road miles. Wife loves heated seats and it
is quiet and the motor and transmission work very well - great
powertrain.

Quote:
But....I just finished replacing a wiper motor assembly on a 98 GM
van, and the local parts store had the part! This tells me a few
things: A) They are failing enough to stock the part and make money
selling them, and B) On the other hand its good to have parts so
readily available.

No offence, but if that is your major complaint, then I don't know what to
say. Parts stores are supposed to have the part you want. Are you telling me
if you walked into a Toyota parts store, and they didn't have your part, you
would walk out saying "wow, I'm so glad they didn't have my part, 'cause it
means they don't break down much"?

It was a local O'Riley autoparts store. I figured it was one of those
freak things where I'd have to go to a junk yard or the dealer to
replace it, but apparently enough fail that they stock them in new and
rebuilt. Guy at the store said they seem to be a weak point as he
gets his share of customers buying them. I had a '65 and '70 Nova and
my sister had a '65 LeMans, My parents had a variety of cars mostly GM
but including a '70 Toyota and a '84 Mazda pickup. Over years and
years of car ownership we never had a wiper system fail before this,
but they were the older design - so go figure.

Also, from doing due dilligiance on the Intrigue, I couldn't help but
notice that for years the vehicle was produced with alternators that
flickered the lights, but GM did not address this for a long time. My
dad also owned 3 1980s/early 90's SSE Bonnevilles and he just about
had to keep a spare alternator in the trunk, they were junk for years
and GM just ignored it. Must have been the bean counters not the
engineers, but hard to keep customers happy when the same part keeps
failing...

Its not just GM though, my since departed '95 Ram PU blew a speedo/odo
unit and power door lock mech right before I sold it, lightening my
wallet considerably even just for parts. Not to mention the tire that
egg shaped as I was marketing it....

GM cars are good for driving the crap out of, they seem to get to a
point of wear but then go for a long time before actually going over
the edge. When you do get an import up in miles, the parts and
difficulty working on some of them makes them a losing proposition.
But the lines are blurring with US plants and US designed import
vehicles...



Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old   
80 Knight
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: window motor - 03-22-2007 , 10:14 PM



"scott" <scott.snowboard (AT) gmail (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
- Show quoted text -

Don't get me wrong, I own two Oldsmobiles!

Which models, if you don't mind me asking?

I have a 98 Olds Silo GLS van, extended with about every option
including rear AC, rear audio entertainment, middle row captain
chairs, trac control, auto leveling, leather, etc. Bought used for
$11k which was good deal and we've used it quite a bit and its been a
good vehicle besides the intake gasket.

I also have a '00 Intrigue GLS with the 3.5 short star motor. Its
also loaded and has the PCS stability control system, 4 wheel disks,
leather, bose, dual climate, sunroof, chrome wheels, etc. I got that
on Ebay for $5k with 90k road miles. Wife loves heated seats and it
is quiet and the motor and transmission work very well - great
powertrain.
I have liked the Intrigue's since I saw one back in '98. I was actually
looking to buy one, but I found my '96 Bonnie first.

Quote:
But....I just finished replacing a wiper motor assembly on a 98 GM
van, and the local parts store had the part! This tells me a few
things: A) They are failing enough to stock the part and make money
selling them, and B) On the other hand its good to have parts so
readily available.

No offence, but if that is your major complaint, then I don't know what
to
say. Parts stores are supposed to have the part you want. Are you telling
me
if you walked into a Toyota parts store, and they didn't have your part,
you
would walk out saying "wow, I'm so glad they didn't have my part, 'cause
it
means they don't break down much"?


It was a local O'Riley autoparts store. I figured it was one of those
freak things where I'd have to go to a junk yard or the dealer to
replace it, but apparently enough fail that they stock them in new and
rebuilt. Guy at the store said they seem to be a weak point as he
gets his share of customers buying them. I had a '65 and '70 Nova and
my sister had a '65 LeMans, My parents had a variety of cars mostly GM
but including a '70 Toyota and a '84 Mazda pickup. Over years and
years of car ownership we never had a wiper system fail before this,
but they were the older design - so go figure.
I guess it depends on where you go, too. I went to a Napa (if memory
serves) once for a module for one of my cars. A Cutlass Supreme, IIRC. The
guy checked the computer, walked into the back, brought it out and blew the
dust off it. Said it had been there quite a few years.

Quote:
Also, from doing due dilligiance on the Intrigue, I couldn't help but
notice that for years the vehicle was produced with alternators that
flickered the lights, but GM did not address this for a long time. My
dad also owned 3 1980s/early 90's SSE Bonnevilles and he just about
had to keep a spare alternator in the trunk, they were junk for years
and GM just ignored it. Must have been the bean counters not the
engineers, but hard to keep customers happy when the same part keeps
failing...
I owned a 1990 and 1991 Bonnie SSE, a 1996 Bonnie SE and now have a 1996
Bonnie SSEi. All of them did the 'flicker'. Never replaced an alternator on
any of them though. *touches wood*. If memory serves, I solved it on the '96
SE by cleaning the battery/alternator cables.

Quote:
Its not just GM though, my since departed '95 Ram PU blew a speedo/odo
unit and power door lock mech right before I sold it, lightening my
wallet considerably even just for parts. Not to mention the tire that
egg shaped as I was marketing it....
Those dash boards are expensive as sin. I had to replace one in the 1990
Bonnie. Well, the dash worked fine (Odo, spedo, ect), but the little
computer's that gave Driver Info and a digital Compass didn't. I thought
they were neat, so I paid $200 (IIRC) for a used one.

Quote:
GM cars are good for driving the crap out of, they seem to get to a
point of wear but then go for a long time before actually going over
the edge. When you do get an import up in miles, the parts and
difficulty working on some of them makes them a losing proposition.
But the lines are blurring with US plants and US designed import
vehicles...
I drive the crap out of my cars, and I always have. The car that took the
most was a 1991 Grand Prix. By time I scraped it with well something like
350,000 on it, it had more dents in it then I could have counted. Not to
mention the multi-colored exterior...all burgundy, just different
'versions' of it...But, she drove all the way to the junk yard, and out ran
my then-new-car '97 Olds Cutlass Supreme. Oh the cars we miss...




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.