AutosTalk Forums  

Gelling in Lexus Engines!

Lexus Discussions about Lexus cars and trucks (alt.autos.lexus)


Discuss Gelling in Lexus Engines! in the Lexus forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #21  
Old   
markjen
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 11:43 AM






Quote:
Most of the Euro makes are stretching oil changes out to 12K+,
albeit on synthetics.

Well actually, in Europe, the fuels have MUCH lower sulphur content
and they have the ACEA oil rating standard that is MUCH more specific
about oil application.
My comment had nothing to do with Europe, it had to do with what European
auto mfgs are recommending insofar as oil change intervals. Buy virtually
any BMW, MB, or Audi in the US and they come with a maintenance reminder
system that tells you when to change the oil. It is a rare car that
recommends an oil change at intervals shorter than 12K miles. I'm not a
believer that these longer intervals are a particularly good idea - I'm just
pointing out that Lexus' 7.5K recommendation is fairly short in this
day/age.

- Mark




Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old   
Philip®
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 11:54 AM






In news:103p6jngl0lr7c2 (AT) news (DOT) supernews.com,
Dan J. S. <me (AT) hyperx (DOT) com> being of bellicose mind posted:
Quote:
Philip® wrote:
In news:103o740bk0br835 (AT) news (DOT) supernews.com,
Dan J. S. <me (AT) hyperx (DOT) com> being of bellicose mind posted:
Steve Jacobs wrote:
Having not owned a Toyota product in over 10 years I'm only
vaguely aware of some sort of problem with Toyota engines and
oil gelling.

I'm now the owner of a new RX330 and seeing references to
this problem. Can you point me to information about this
problem?

I think the problem is that Toyota now recommends oil changes
every 7500 miles, which in my opinion is CRAZY. So you have
people that wait till 7500 and then say "Oh I will do it next
week" - and that drags onto 10,000 miles. I change my oil
every 3k. This is on my ES330 (which hasnt hit 3k yet) and my
4 runner.

The "problem" *was* .... the 7,500 mile intervals that NOBODY in
the real world qualified for in the first place and then ....
exceeded, just like you say!

My 2003 4 runner manual still says 7,500. The dealer reminds me
that I don't need to come back every 3k miles if I don't want to.
I do not remember what my es330 booklet says but that may have a
5k recommendation.
Dare I paraphrase myself from earlier: "Nobody in the real world
qualifies for the 7,500 mile service interval." To that would add
.... "in America using OUR fuels and OUR API graded oils." Just
covering myself because it is apparent there are some people quoting
European practices without a greater of awarness as to WHY the
European markets can run longer oil service intervals with little
concern over sludging. Not that they're immune to sludge ... not by
any stretch.
--

- Philip @ Maximum Torque RPM




Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old   
Dan J. S.
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 02:22 PM




Quote:
My 2003 4 runner manual still says 7,500. The dealer reminds me
that I don't need to come back every 3k miles if I don't want to.
I do not remember what my es330 booklet says but that may have a
5k recommendation.

Dare I paraphrase myself from earlier: "Nobody in the real world
qualifies for the 7,500 mile service interval." To that would add
... "in America using OUR fuels and OUR API graded oils." Just
covering myself because it is apparent there are some people quoting
European practices without a greater of awarness as to WHY the
European markets can run longer oil service intervals with little
concern over sludging. Not that they're immune to sludge ... not by
any stretch.
--
I understand your point, by if Joe Schmoe gets told by the dealer and the
manual to change the oil every 7500 miles, he will not think about it more
than that. You know a lot about cars, etc. Average Joe goes by what the
dealer says. If you do everything the dealer and Toyota recommend, you
should not be held accountable if you engine develops the sliming issue.
There is enough margin to reach a compromising medium.




Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old   
Philip®
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 02:57 PM



In news:103ptg4l135t60 (AT) news (DOT) supernews.com,
Dan J. S. <me (AT) hyperx (DOT) com> being of bellicose mind posted:
Quote:
My 2003 4 runner manual still says 7,500. The dealer reminds me
that I don't need to come back every 3k miles if I don't want
to. I do not remember what my es330 booklet says but that may
have a 5k recommendation.

Dare I paraphrase myself from earlier: "Nobody in the real world
qualifies for the 7,500 mile service interval." To that would
add ... "in America using OUR fuels and OUR API graded oils."
Just covering myself because it is apparent there are some
people quoting European practices without a greater of awarness
as to WHY the European markets can run longer oil service
intervals with little concern over sludging. Not that they're
immune to sludge ... not by any stretch.
--

I understand your point, by if Joe Schmoe gets told by the dealer
and the manual to change the oil every 7500 miles, he will not
think about it more than that. You know a lot about cars, etc.
Average Joe goes by what the dealer says. If you do everything
the dealer and Toyota recommend, you should not be held
accountable if you engine develops the sliming issue. There is
enough margin to reach a compromising medium.
It is truely (a) unlikely a dealer would recommend the 7,500 mile
intervals and (b) a pity that a dealer would recommend the 7,500 mile
intervals in the light of the gelling hysteria.

Having said all that, I don't really disagree with you about who and
what the new owner will listen to. In my case, my dealer has
winshield stickers and a mailed out reminder program about oil
changes .... at 3,500 miles with the hopes that I'll show up at 5,000
miles.
--

- Philip @ Maximum Torque RPM








Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old   
Bob Huntley
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 04:26 PM



For Peugeot cars (my last make of car) they went to 20,000 miles for petrol
cars, 10,000 for diesels a couple of years ago (with synthetic oil).
I'm a bit mystified - why does the USA seem to feel the need for such
frequent mile oil changes.

My UK spec Lexus IS200 has a 10,000 mile service interval (and no need for
synthetic oil). But I understand that the mechanically very similar US IS300
requires 5000 mile services - why?



"markjen" <mark.jennings4 (AT) comcast (DOT) net> wrote

Quote:
I think the problem is that Toyota now recommends oil changes every 7500
miles, which in my opinion is CRAZY.

Well, it is actually pretty conservative in this day and age. Most of the
Euro makes are stretching oil changes out to 12K+, albeit on synthetics.

- Mark





Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old   
Philip®
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Gelling in Lexus Engines! - 02-25-2004 , 07:19 PM



It is not a *feeling* that intervals need to be less than 7,500 miles
here. It's a fact. VW tried the Euro intervals and found themselves
faced with sludge claims. There are SL oils that might survive 7,500
miles under ideal conditions (that no common man can duplicate) and
there are SL oils that exceed that capability. But API gives no
clue. ACEA does.

Fuel sulfur levels are much lower in Europe ... with the exception
here of California which is fairly close to Euro standards,
particularly with diesel. Also, your ACEA oil rating system is far
more specific than our minimum threshold API ratings.
--

- Philip @ Maximum Torque RPM


In news:c1j3tq$oph$1 (AT) sparta (DOT) btinternet.com,
Bob Huntley <bob.huntley.NOSPAM (AT) btinternet (DOT) com> being of bellicose
mind posted:
Quote:
For Peugeot cars (my last make of car) they went to 20,000 miles
for petrol cars, 10,000 for diesels a couple of years ago (with
synthetic oil).
I'm a bit mystified - why does the USA seem to feel the need for
such frequent mile oil changes.

My UK spec Lexus IS200 has a 10,000 mile service interval (and no
need for synthetic oil). But I understand that the mechanically
very similar US IS300 requires 5000 mile services - why?



"markjen" <mark.jennings4 (AT) comcast (DOT) net> wrote in message
news:KOW_b.54193$Xp.259706 (AT) attbi_s54 (DOT) ..
I think the problem is that Toyota now recommends oil changes
every 7500 miles, which in my opinion is CRAZY.

Well, it is actually pretty conservative in this day and age.
Most of the Euro makes are stretching oil changes out to 12K+,
albeit on synthetics.

- Mark




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.