AutosTalk Forums  

W123 Coupe Door Closing

Mercedes-Benz Mercedes-Benz Cars Discussions (alt.auto.mercedes)


Discuss W123 Coupe Door Closing in the Mercedes-Benz forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
Commuter
 
Posts: n/a

Default W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-02-2009 , 09:51 AM






The 230CE is coming along well. The 5-speed was worth the effort. The cruise
control works most of the time. The AC is almost ready to fill I just have
to add one more fitting. The power windows are nice.

As I am driving it more on thing is frustrating me: With the windows up it
is difficult to close the door. It often does not close right the first try
and I have to open it ant push hard to get it closed. If the passinger
window is open, the drivers door closes nicely. The problem is I'll slam the
door if the a window is open because I am used to a harder push when the
windows are up.

I tried to check the vent outlet for blockage but I can't find a path for
the air to go out. I can only guess that the air must flow out the hole
around the rear upper seat belt mount.

Any Ideas?

Thanks

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Roland Franzius
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-02-2009 , 01:26 PM






Commuter schrieb:
Quote:
The 230CE is coming along well. The 5-speed was worth the effort. The cruise
control works most of the time. The AC is almost ready to fill I just have
to add one more fitting. The power windows are nice.

As I am driving it more on thing is frustrating me: With the windows up it
is difficult to close the door. It often does not close right the first try
and I have to open it ant push hard to get it closed. If the passinger
window is open, the drivers door closes nicely. The problem is I'll slam the
door if the a window is open because I am used to a harder push when the
windows are up.

I tried to check the vent outlet for blockage but I can't find a path for
the air to go out. I can only guess that the air must flow out the hole
around the rear upper seat belt mount.

Any Ideas?
I think the air is going down between rear window and cover in full
width of the car. There is an flat air duct below in the trunk to the
outlets on both C-columns. The manifold is in danger of rusting through
to the window frame in older cars.

--

Roland Franzius

Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Commuter
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-03-2009 , 12:23 PM



I removed the trim on the rear deck and you are right that is the way it
works. There is a small gap between the trim piece and the window. There is
no blockage that I can see. If I remove the first aid kit and open the
trunk, the doors close nicely. I wonder if they did not correct for the
larger doors of a coupe and not provide for more air flow. Do sedans have
this problem? I rode in a BMW that when the door is opened the window opens
a bit then goes up when the door is closed. This prevents the problem that I
am having. I may design a circuit to do this on my car.

I alwys wondered if they still called it a C-column (pilar) even though this
is a "Pillarless Coupe" and there is no B-column.

Thanks for your response.


"Roland Franzius" <roland.franzius (AT) uos (DOT) de> wrote

Quote:
Commuter schrieb:
The 230CE is coming along well. The 5-speed was worth the effort. The
cruise control works most of the time. The AC is almost ready to fill I
just have to add one more fitting. The power windows are nice.

As I am driving it more on thing is frustrating me: With the windows up
it is difficult to close the door. It often does not close right the
first try and I have to open it ant push hard to get it closed. If the
passinger window is open, the drivers door closes nicely. The problem is
I'll slam the door if the a window is open because I am used to a harder
push when the windows are up.

I tried to check the vent outlet for blockage but I can't find a path for
the air to go out. I can only guess that the air must flow out the hole
around the rear upper seat belt mount.

Any Ideas?

I think the air is going down between rear window and cover in full width
of the car. There is an flat air duct below in the trunk to the outlets on
both C-columns. The manifold is in danger of rusting through to the window
frame in older cars.

--

Roland Franzius

Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old   
Roland Franzius
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-03-2009 , 01:24 PM



Commuter schrieb:
Quote:
I removed the trim on the rear deck and you are right that is the way it
works. There is a small gap between the trim piece and the window. There is
no blockage that I can see. If I remove the first aid kit and open the
trunk, the doors close nicely. I wonder if they did not correct for the
larger doors of a coupe and not provide for more air flow. Do sedans have
this problem? I rode in a BMW that when the door is opened the window opens
a bit then goes up when the door is closed. This prevents the problem that I
am having. I may design a circuit to do this on my car.

I alwys wondered if they still called it a C-column (pilar) even though this
is a "Pillarless Coupe" and there is no B-column.

Thanks for your response.


"Roland Franzius" <roland.franzius (AT) uos (DOT) de> wrote in message
news:h2iqki$kgu$00$1 (AT) news (DOT) t-online.com...
Commuter schrieb:
The 230CE is coming along well. The 5-speed was worth the effort. The
cruise control works most of the time. The AC is almost ready to fill I
just have to add one more fitting. The power windows are nice.

As I am driving it more on thing is frustrating me: With the windows up
it is difficult to close the door. It often does not close right the
first try and I have to open it ant push hard to get it closed. If the
passinger window is open, the drivers door closes nicely. The problem is
I'll slam the door if the a window is open because I am used to a harder
push when the windows are up.

I tried to check the vent outlet for blockage but I can't find a path for
the air to go out. I can only guess that the air must flow out the hole
around the rear upper seat belt mount.

Any Ideas?
I think the air is going down between rear window and cover in full width
of the car. There is an flat air duct below in the trunk to the outlets on
both C-columns. The manifold is in danger of rusting through to the window
frame in older cars.
The sudden pressure rise is best seen with a convertible when slamming a
door is blowing up the hood.

Suddenly closing one door in a tenth of a second adds perhaps 50 liters
of air to the inner of the car.

Newtonian air flow physics and the look at the convertible tells you the
time to reach pressure equilibrium again is greater than a second.

So for the reaction force the air ducts have no significant effect
during the closing time. An open sunroof or partly opened window will
have.

The compression ratio of the passenger cell volume is something like
50 l /10000 l making a net pressure of 50 mbar or 500 kg/square meter.

The door surface of perhaps 1/4 square meter has to overcome a force of
roughly 125-250 kg.

--

Roland Franzius

Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old   
Cordy
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-03-2009 , 02:15 PM



Commuter ha scritto:
Quote:
I rode in a BMW that when the door is opened the window opens
a bit then goes up when the door is closed. This prevents the problem that I
am having.
Yes, that BMW window strange behaviour helps to prevent the problem that
you have wih your Mercedes. But the reason is different: on the BMW it
avoids crushing the capote (the fabric of the roof).

I'd suggest to check below the doors and on the two sides of the rear
seats, if there are any air passages closed by leaves, dust, dirt, etc.

Bye-bye. Stefano from Italy

Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old   
Roland Franzius
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-03-2009 , 06:13 PM



Cordy schrieb:
Quote:
Commuter ha scritto:
I rode in a BMW that when the door is opened the window opens a bit
then goes up when the door is closed. This prevents the problem that I
am having.

Yes, that BMW window strange behaviour helps to prevent the problem that
you have wih your Mercedes. But the reason is different: on the BMW it
avoids crushing the capote (the fabric of the roof).
The SLK has the feature of open windows during closing the doors since
2000. Probably people have complained because of the ear shock.

--

Roland Franzius

Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old   
Dori A Schmetterling
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-03-2009 , 06:48 PM



As does my CLK Cabrio. Window drops slightly then rises again after closing
the door. I think that's mainly to ensure the door and roof fabric don't
'tangle'.

BTW, very occasionally the window drops a lot and won't close properly. The
official fix is to fiddle about in a certain way with the window control...

DAS

To send an e-mail directly replace "spam" with "schmetterling"
---
"Roland Franzius" <roland.franzius (AT) uos (DOT) de> wrote

[...]
Quote:
The SLK has the feature of open windows during closing the doors since
2000. Probably people have complained because of the ear shock.

--

Roland Franzius

Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old   
Commuter
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-04-2009 , 12:14 AM



Since the power window circuit is engerized when the drivers door is opened,
my new circuit will be fairly simple. Probably one 555 timer, one relay and
a few resisitors and capacitors.

After removing the first aid kit, I realised that the trunk closes eaiser
too if the doors are open. There is not much I can do about this.

"Dori A Schmetterling" <nobody (AT) spam (DOT) co.uk> wrote

Quote:
As does my CLK Cabrio. Window drops slightly then rises again after
closing the door. I think that's mainly to ensure the door and roof
fabric don't 'tangle'.

BTW, very occasionally the window drops a lot and won't close properly.
The official fix is to fiddle about in a certain way with the window
control...

DAS

To send an e-mail directly replace "spam" with "schmetterling"
---
"Roland Franzius" <roland.franzius (AT) uos (DOT) de> wrote in message
news:h2lvp0$2c5$01$1 (AT) news (DOT) t-online.com...
[...]

The SLK has the feature of open windows during closing the doors since
2000. Probably people have complained because of the ear shock.

--

Roland Franzius


Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old   
Kenneth P. Stox
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-04-2009 , 12:41 AM



Commuter wrote:
Quote:
I rode in a BMW that when the door is opened the window opens
a bit then goes up when the door is closed. This prevents the problem that I
am having. I may design a circuit to do this on my car.
Mercedes W140 Coupes do this too.

Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old   
Tiger
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: W123 Coupe Door Closing - 07-04-2009 , 09:56 AM



There is vent flaps in the trunk. On W126, it is located in the side pockets
in the trunk toward the spare tire There should be a hole and a rubber flap
on each side. Pretty big oval hole.

I am wondering if someone replaced those side pockets as a possibility of
rust. Without this vent, your AC won't work well either... there got to be
some vent to prevent building up pressure as you drive faster.

Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.