AutosTalk Forums  

Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think...

Miscellaneous UK car topics Other UK car topics (uk.rec.cars.misc)


Discuss Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... in the Miscellaneous UK car topics forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
Mike P
 
Posts: n/a

Default Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-19-2003 , 03:39 PM






THIS IS A LONG, AND POSSIBLY BORING POST. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED :-)

Quote:

Just had a call from my mum. She's decided she wants to change her car.
She's fed up with buying new
and only wants to spend around £4-4500.

Here's what she's looking for.

light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy hatches".

My mum has had 5 cars in her driving career.

2 2CVs
A lada 1200 saloon
A Vitara (bought new)
A Jimny (bought new)

She wants a car nicer on the motorway than that lot too. She does about 6k
per year, mostly around town. Takes my doddery gran out quite often.

Now, here's the crunch. My mum's weird. She will NOT trail round car dealers
and private sales looking at each car. She treats the car like an appliance,
not a vehicle. What it is, how it drives, is not important to her at all as
long as it does what she wants. She is not interested in shopping for a car.
I have to do that for her. She has better things to do with her time. She
hates driving, in that it is a waste of her time. She is actually a good
driver.

Example - she saw Jimny in the paper, and said "I want one.. sort it out.
Here's the cash". So I did. I told her it was a pile of shit, and I told
her she should drive the bloody thing first. I had to get them to bring the
car to her though for her to finally do so. I still told her it was shit,
but she said "well, it's a lot lighter than the Vitara"... I'll have it.
Refused point blank then to try a "normal" car instead - because of the
ground clearance issue and bought it. New. 12 months ago. Now, she's finally
twigged it's shit, and wants to get rid and get a conventional car! This
only happened as she got forced to use a Ka as a courtesy car, and much
preffered it. So that is my task.....

Any ideas what car I should get her? She usually keeps them for a while
too - the Vitara she bought new and had for 11 years..

She is a PITA to deal with too.. but hey, she's my mum, and she's that
strange that it's funny!


Any ideas gratefully received!

Mike




Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Stephen Leslie
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-19-2003 , 05:00 PM






Hi Mike,

Not sure about the ground clearance but my mum has a Toyota Starlet 3dr
which she is very happy with.

I know there is a 5dr version and hers is very nippy with power steering.
The boot is not the largest but it will do.

She got it from my cousin 3/4yrs ago who works for VW and its never had one
fault. Very reliable.

I considered getting it but it was just too small for my liking, so ended up
with a Octavia instead.

As the Starlet's not been around a while it may be better to check out the
Toyota Yaris instead as it seems to get good reviews as well.

Cheers,
Stephen
"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
THIS IS A LONG, AND POSSIBLY BORING POST. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED :-)




Just had a call from my mum. She's decided she wants to change her car.
She's fed up with buying new
and only wants to spend around £4-4500.

Here's what she's looking for.

light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy hatches".

My mum has had 5 cars in her driving career.

2 2CVs
A lada 1200 saloon
A Vitara (bought new)
A Jimny (bought new)

She wants a car nicer on the motorway than that lot too. She does about 6k
per year, mostly around town. Takes my doddery gran out quite often.

Now, here's the crunch. My mum's weird. She will NOT trail round car
dealers
and private sales looking at each car. She treats the car like an
appliance,
not a vehicle. What it is, how it drives, is not important to her at all
as
long as it does what she wants. She is not interested in shopping for a
car.
I have to do that for her. She has better things to do with her time. She
hates driving, in that it is a waste of her time. She is actually a good
driver.

Example - she saw Jimny in the paper, and said "I want one.. sort it out.
Here's the cash". So I did. I told her it was a pile of shit, and I told
her she should drive the bloody thing first. I had to get them to bring
the
car to her though for her to finally do so. I still told her it was shit,
but she said "well, it's a lot lighter than the Vitara"... I'll have it.
Refused point blank then to try a "normal" car instead - because of the
ground clearance issue and bought it. New. 12 months ago. Now, she's
finally
twigged it's shit, and wants to get rid and get a conventional car! This
only happened as she got forced to use a Ka as a courtesy car, and much
preffered it. So that is my task.....

Any ideas what car I should get her? She usually keeps them for a while
too - the Vitara she bought new and had for 11 years..

She is a PITA to deal with too.. but hey, she's my mum, and she's that
strange that it's funny!


Any ideas gratefully received!

Mike





Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Mike P
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-19-2003 , 05:20 PM




"Stephen Leslie" <stephenleslie (AT) blueyonder (DOT) co.uk> wrote

Quote:
Hi Mike,

Not sure about the ground clearance but my mum has a Toyota Starlet 3dr
which she is very happy with.

I know there is a 5dr version and hers is very nippy with power steering.
The boot is not the largest but it will do.

She got it from my cousin 3/4yrs ago who works for VW and its never had
one
fault. Very reliable.

I considered getting it but it was just too small for my liking, so ended
up
with a Octavia instead.

As the Starlet's not been around a while it may be better to check out the
Toyota Yaris instead as it seems to get good reviews as well.


Thanks for the suggestion Steve. The Yaris was something I'd not thought
about. Having a look on Autotrader they
look like they might have enough clearance - long wheelbase cars suffer more
on that road - they bottom out in the middle because of the initial drop.
Pricewise they look spot on, and we all know they don't break down.

Mike




Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old   
JM
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-20-2003 , 01:42 AM




"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
THIS IS A LONG, AND POSSIBLY BORING POST. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED :-)




Just had a call from my mum. She's decided she wants to change her car.
She's fed up with buying new
and only wants to spend around £4-4500.

Here's what she's looking for.

light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy hatches".
oh well, there goes my suggestion (corsa 1.7 diesel)




Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old   
pete boyall
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-20-2003 , 04:16 AM



On Fri, 19 Dec 2003 23:20:30 -0000, "Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com>
wrote:

<snip>
Quote:
Thanks for the suggestion Steve. The Yaris was something I'd not thought
about. Having a look on Autotrader they
look like they might have enough clearance - long wheelbase cars suffer more
on that road - they bottom out in the middle because of the initial drop.
Pricewise they look spot on, and we all know they don't break down.
"And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy
hatches"."

?
--
Pete
Cut out the carp to reply.


Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old   
Mike P
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-20-2003 , 04:57 AM




"pete boyall" <pboyall.spamblock (AT) _nospam_ (DOT) IHATESPAM.lineone.co.uk> wrote in
message news:3fe4215a.2996408 (AT) news (DOT) btopenworld.com...
Quote:
On Fri, 19 Dec 2003 23:20:30 -0000, "Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com
wrote:

snip

Thanks for the suggestion Steve. The Yaris was something I'd not thought
about. Having a look on Autotrader they
look like they might have enough clearance - long wheelbase cars suffer
more
on that road - they bottom out in the middle because of the initial drop.
Pricewise they look spot on, and we all know they don't break down.

"And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy
hatches"."

?
--
Pete
Exactly. You don't know my mum :-) a Yaris doesn't look normal to her....
Fiesta, etc does. I know they all look similar, but this is my mum we're on
about.. don't try and make sense of it please. You can't. I've been trying
for 30 years!

Mike






Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old   
Mike P
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-20-2003 , 04:59 AM





"JM" <me8 (AT) privacy (DOT) net> wrote

Quote:
"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:brvr7d$8784o$1 (AT) ID-163316 (DOT) news.uni-berlin.de...
THIS IS A LONG, AND POSSIBLY BORING POST. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED :-)




Just had a call from my mum. She's decided she wants to change her car.
She's fed up with buying new
and only wants to spend around £4-4500.

Here's what she's looking for.

light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in
anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy
hatches".

oh well, there goes my suggestion (corsa 1.7 diesel)

Not necessarily. My brother and I are slowly convincing her to get a more
conventional car.. at least we've got her away from the Suzuki 4WD stuff...
lets see how far we can get her to normality!

Cheers

Mike




Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old   
Budgie
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-20-2003 , 05:09 AM



"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote


Quote:
light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy hatches".
Daihatsu Terios

Budgie


---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.552 / Virus Database: 344 - Release Date: 15/12/2003




Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old   
Gaynor
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Help!! Suggest a car for my mum! Not as easy as you think... - 12-21-2003 , 05:44 PM




"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:

"JM" <me8 (AT) privacy (DOT) net> wrote in message
news:c3TEb.7001$FN.4636 (AT) newsfep4-winn (DOT) server.ntli.net...

"Mike P" <stickit (AT) up-uranus (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:brvr7d$8784o$1 (AT) ID-163316 (DOT) news.uni-berlin.de...
THIS IS A LONG, AND POSSIBLY BORING POST. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED :-)




Just had a call from my mum. She's decided she wants to change her
car.
She's fed up with buying new
and only wants to spend around £4-4500.

Here's what she's looking for.

light to drive/easy to
4 doors with legroom for a 5'6" aunt in the back
economical - "preferably a diesel"
Small ish - she asked me if they do a 4-dr Ka(!!)
Reasonable stereo
Good ground clearance - the top entrance to our road is a very steep
downhill unmade road all of literally 4 yds long, but it goes
"flat-steep-not so steep" very quickly. Too steep to drive UP in
anything
other than a 2CV or 4WD. A Berlingo van has enough clearance, the
mondeo
bottoms out , the Saab has no chance!

And... it "hasn't to be too normal. I don't like all these boxy
hatches".

oh well, there goes my suggestion (corsa 1.7 diesel)


Not necessarily. My brother and I are slowly convincing her to get a more
conventional car.. at least we've got her away from the Suzuki 4WD
stuff...
lets see how far we can get her to normality!

Cheers

Mike


If she likes a car that feels higher than it is try one of the new Nissan
Micras - I have learnt to drive in one of the old one (low and crap) and one
of the new ones (feels like the Starship Enterprise). It is a lot higher and
handles superbly on dual carriageway and around town - new sleek lines too -
nothing like the old type - well worth a look. I know about low cars - I
have a Rover 214 - feels like your sitting in a go-cart and handles like one
too.

Gaynor




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.