AutosTalk Forums  

Mexico

Nascar NASCAR and other professional stock car racing (rec.autos.sport.nascar)


Discuss Mexico in the Nascar forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old   
SimRacer
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Mexico - into immigration - 03-08-2006 , 03:11 PM







"a425couple" <a425couple (AT) hotmail (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
"SimRacer" <nOspaM@simracer68 (AT) yahoo (DOT) com> wrote
"Carey Akin" <cmakin (AT) att (DOT) net> wrote in
"WildWeasel" <wweasel_24 (AT) HooYah (DOT) com> wrote
--nascar thinks there (is) --- disposable income in Mexico
Believe it or not, and without the racist overtones, that is not too
far
from the truth. What is the entire population of the state of
Kentucky?
Mexico City alone has 18 million, plus. Big market there alone.
And to Weasel's point, it may not be that far off.

I also think that the NASCAR Busch race in Mexico City
makes good sense, for sports organization and for fans.
Decent two way trade and interaction.
Win - win.

Our lovely Prez seems to think that NAFTA
and various other trade agreements in place with Mexico are
necessary to "build a middle class" down there, and presumably stop
the flood of illegals that come here to do that very thing. Whatever.

Ok, but being realistic, nothing will "stop" it, but improving
Mexico's economy will reduce the pressures and "slow" it.

I don't mind being the melting pot nation, just as long as the
immigrants come here legally, get a SS number (and pay their
taxes) and learn the language. That's my one big stickler about
Mexican immigrants to our area (NC has had a huge influx over
the past decade), and that's their reluctance to even attempt to
learn English. Call me a racist if you must, but I don't think it's
our place to learn their language if they're going to live here

I will not call you anything unpleasant.
A number of your concerns have a valid base.
I'd just like to mention some current and historical trends.
Any time you have a large number of immigrants, there
are frictions (1600s, 1800s, 1900s, now.)
(English, Germans, Irish, Italians, Swedish, Norwegians etc.)
Language is certainly one point of friction.

Historically a fair number of the generation that moves,
are slow in changing their language (always has been).
The children (second generation) quite quickly in school
pick up the common language, and often speak both.
Traditionally the third generation has little ties with old.

Example 1, my grandmother came around 1900, never
became very good with English. My father did not speak
English until started first grade. I only know maybe ten
words from the 'old language'.
Example 2, my neighborhood grade school is now 1/3
"English Second Language". I've done some tutoring.
Native languages are real mix of Spanish, 'ex-USSR',
Vietnamese, Chinese etc. By HS graduation they are
quite intermixed. Some do excellent, some medium,
and some poorly.
Example 3, about 3 houses away, great success, 4 kids,
believe 3 have graduated college, all served military,
all doing well in helping contribute to their country, USA.

So IMHO we need to show some patience, understanding,
and some kindness. Almost all of us have immigrant roots.
The vitality of immigration has greatly helped the USA.


That's all and good, and as I also stated, I am not anti-immigration. I just
live in an area that has had a huge influx of Mexican nationals that
apparently are refusing to attempt to learn the language at all. To the
point that NC now prints beaucoup DMV Driver License handbooks in Spanish.
In SPANISH! In NC-USA! At a cost burden predominantly borne of us relatively
native NC tax payers. And I resent it greatly.

So, do they print similar government papers in Mexico in English? Why not?
Turnabout is fair play afterall.

Yes, there are fine folks from Mexico that live here, can converse in the
local language, and as Carey said above, work hard and want to live the
American dream just like everyone else here. But for the majority of NC
Mexican immigrants, learning English simply appears to be a burden that they
don't want to effort, at all. I have been patient, since they changed from
being largely "migrant workers" in the 1970s and 1980s to "permanent
immigrants" in the 1990s to today, I think it's about high time they learn
the langauge if they're going to continue to live among us and become part
of our population. If I were to move to France, I'd effort learning French
(beyond my high school French). If I moved to Mexico, I'd certainly try to
learn Spanish, and as quickly as I could too. Why can't the immigrants to
our country reciprocate? Why should we lower our expectations for them just
because they're "new here"?

Of course I won't go into the burden that these unlisted, paid under the
table, no tax paying immigrants are putting on our schools and medical
facilities. They certainly use the services, but for free. Again, at
bonafide tax payer expense. So you be patient. Me, I'm tired of paying my
way, and the way of countless others that refuse to stand up and be counted
(ie: be here legally, and pay taxes) on top of refusing to speak the local
language. They are, IMO, adding to a bloated size welfare class that was
bulging at the seams with Americans long before they decided to cross the
Rio Grande to get in on the act too. For the ones that come here legally and
actually try to assimilate and become a contributing member of our society,
I say welcome. And have said welcome, to many of our Southern friends.

One of my best neighbors in my subdivision is now a US citizen, that moved
here from Mexico as a 19 year old some years ago. He, his wife & kids (and
parents that live with them) all speak incredibly passable English, work
hard (he owns a landscaping business) and is an all around really nice
family. They can do it, why can't their peers? (Jose even gets more irate
about the above topics than I do, says it sometimes embarrases him that "so
many of his people" won't put forth a genuine effort to fit in to their new
country, that has so graciously taken them in (his words, not mine)). All I
do is nod, and raise my (any brand of Mexican beer Jose has on hand) in
agreement with him...usually as one of his blindfolded kids or some niece or
nephew is swinging some stick at the paper donkey hanging from a nearby
tree... ;-) They do know how to have a good time when it's warranted, as an
aside. I've never so looked forward to May 5th as I have the past few years
having Jose & Maria in our neighborhood. We go to their bash on Cinco de
Mayo (sp? lol) and they come to our July 4th bash each year since they built
here. (And no, they're not exactly token examples of their nationality in
our neighborhood. There are quite simply only 5 houses in our neighborhood,
so I guess they represent roughly 20% of it...) I guess having them as an
example of what an immigrant family (from anywhere, not just Mexico) *can*
do if they try, frustrates me to no end when I see scores of others, in
similar situations, not even trying.




Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old   
Carey Akin
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Mexico - into immigration - 03-08-2006 , 04:01 PM







"SimRacer" <nOspaM@simracer68 (AT) yahoo (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:

That's all and good, and as I also stated, I am not anti-immigration. I
just
live in an area that has had a huge influx of Mexican nationals that
apparently are refusing to attempt to learn the language at all. To the
point that NC now prints beaucoup DMV Driver License handbooks in Spanish.
In SPANISH! In NC-USA! At a cost burden predominantly borne of us
relatively
native NC tax payers. And I resent it greatly.

So, do they print similar government papers in Mexico in English? Why not?
Turnabout is fair play afterall.

Yes, there are fine folks from Mexico that live here, can converse in the
local language, and as Carey said above, work hard and want to live the
American dream just like everyone else here. But for the majority of NC
Mexican immigrants, learning English simply appears to be a burden that
they
don't want to effort, at all. I have been patient, since they changed from
being largely "migrant workers" in the 1970s and 1980s to "permanent
immigrants" in the 1990s to today, I think it's about high time they learn
the langauge if they're going to continue to live among us and become part
of our population. If I were to move to France, I'd effort learning French
(beyond my high school French). If I moved to Mexico, I'd certainly try to
learn Spanish, and as quickly as I could too. Why can't the immigrants to
our country reciprocate? Why should we lower our expectations for them
just
because they're "new here"?

Of course I won't go into the burden that these unlisted, paid under the
table, no tax paying immigrants are putting on our schools and medical
facilities. They certainly use the services, but for free. Again, at
bonafide tax payer expense. So you be patient. Me, I'm tired of paying my
way, and the way of countless others that refuse to stand up and be
counted
(ie: be here legally, and pay taxes) on top of refusing to speak the local
language. They are, IMO, adding to a bloated size welfare class that was
bulging at the seams with Americans long before they decided to cross the
Rio Grande to get in on the act too. For the ones that come here legally
and
actually try to assimilate and become a contributing member of our
society,
I say welcome. And have said welcome, to many of our Southern friends.

One of my best neighbors in my subdivision is now a US citizen, that moved
here from Mexico as a 19 year old some years ago. He, his wife & kids (and
parents that live with them) all speak incredibly passable English, work
hard (he owns a landscaping business) and is an all around really nice
family. They can do it, why can't their peers? (Jose even gets more irate
about the above topics than I do, says it sometimes embarrases him that
"so
many of his people" won't put forth a genuine effort to fit in to their
new
country, that has so graciously taken them in (his words, not mine)). All
I
do is nod, and raise my (any brand of Mexican beer Jose has on hand) in
agreement with him...usually as one of his blindfolded kids or some niece
or
nephew is swinging some stick at the paper donkey hanging from a nearby
tree... ;-) They do know how to have a good time when it's warranted, as
an
aside. I've never so looked forward to May 5th as I have the past few
years
having Jose & Maria in our neighborhood. We go to their bash on Cinco de
Mayo (sp? lol) and they come to our July 4th bash each year since they
built
here. (And no, they're not exactly token examples of their nationality in
our neighborhood. There are quite simply only 5 houses in our
neighborhood,
so I guess they represent roughly 20% of it...) I guess having them as an
example of what an immigrant family (from anywhere, not just Mexico) *can*
do if they try, frustrates me to no end when I see scores of others, in
similar situations, not even trying.

As you stated, you are only assuming that this new group of immigrants isn't
trying to learn English. There are many here in the Houston area, and many
that don't speak English, but our demographic is far different from yours.
That said, most of the immigrants here now are like José when he first moved
here. Unfortunately, it is the gang members (an most of those are Honduran)
and the criminals that get all the media attention. Someone trying to be a
good citizen doesn't ever make the news. As I stated, much of this problem
would go away if employers were forced to obey the citizenship laws in
place, but they aren't and it is hard for a contractor to compete in a
business where so many others do. As a whole, I find Mexican people to be
hard workers, much so more than here (try to work down there and finish
before seven in the evening). Even those that are working, may be working
off the books, but they are paying taxes in the form of sales taxes,
property taxes (as part of their rent), etc. Most do not want to avail
themselves of welfare, since they are wary of making their presence known in
this country for fear of being sent back. And, no, there is very little
printed material, especially from the government down in Mexico that is in
English. That I do find interesting, since Mexico is much a country of
immigrants, as is the US. Again, this isn't noticeable to most folks who
live here, since the middle class, primarily of all European descent,
doesn't have the need to come to the US for work. It is the poor resident,
of Indian descent, living in a village long forgotten that comes here for
work. As I again state. This isn't a real big issue for me, but I do feel
that, as an illegal, they should be treated as such and sent home. Dry up
the jobs up here for them and they won't come over. In the long run, we are
better served by an economically stronger Mexico. With the youth coming up
there, I hope to see it in my lifetime, as well as being a part of it.
Afterall, there is money to be made down there.

Carey in Manvel




Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old   
WildWeasel
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Mexico - into immigration - 03-08-2006 , 04:25 PM




"SimRacer" wrote ...
Quote:

That's all ... (snip a great rant for the ages, otherwise algore's internet
will get cloggged)
....
I guess having them as an
example of what an immigrant family (from anywhere, not just Mexico) *can*
do if they try, frustrates me to no end when I see scores of others, in
similar situations, not even trying.

can somebody give Sim an amen? AMEN!

On Quattro de Mayo I'll salute me and on Cinco de Mayo I'll hoist one for Sim's
good neighbor, and fine American, Jose! (and on 6th de Mayo I'll be in
Richmond! What a weekend!)




Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old   
John McCoy
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Mexico - into immigration - 03-08-2006 , 08:34 PM



"SimRacer" <nOspaM@simracer68 (AT) yahoo (DOT) com> wrote in
news:UTGPf.57668$%84.39278 (AT) tornado (DOT) southeast.rr.com:

Quote:
That's all and good, and as I also stated, I am not anti-immigration.
I just live in an area that has had a huge influx of Mexican nationals
that apparently are refusing to attempt to learn the language at all.
How closely do you interact with these people? Virtually every
Hispanic that I know well (who, admittedly, are primarily Cubans;
there's relatively few Mexicans in South Fla) has repeatedly
expressed a desire to speak better English. The few exceptions
mostly speak it better than I do.

I'll also note that desiring to speak English well, and actually
being able to do so are different things - some people do not
pick up languages easily, and the tendency of lower economic
status immigrants to group together reduces their opportunities
for practice.

John


Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.