AutosTalk Forums  

Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ...

Porsche Discussions About Porsche Automobiles (alt.autos.porsche)


Discuss Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... in the Porsche forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #21  
Old   
Eisboch
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 01:44 PM







"Walter Spector" <w6ws_xthisoutx (AT) earthlink (DOT) net> wrote

Quote:
Well, you guys "made me look".

Heh. This "debate" made me recall an incident unrelated to Porsche, but
involving Audi.
Back in the early 80's I had a work associate who bought an Audi 4000. He
was a bit of a snob and was always reminding us of how refined his car and
engine was compared to the cheap American junk the rest of us drove.

One day he popped the hood and was showing off his engine. I looked at it
and realized it looked very familiar.
So, I went over and popped the hood on my '79 Dodge Omni and sure enough, it
was basically the same engine except the Omni had a carburetor and the Audi
was fuel injected. Everything below the manifold was pretty much the same.

I called him over and said, "Hey, look! I've got the same engine in my
Omni!"

He was BS and traded the Audi for a 124 Fiat Spyder.

Turns out that as Chrysler was reorganizing they didn't have an available
engine for the Omni/Horizon so they outsourced them to VW or Audi or whoever
was building the engine.

Eisboch




Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old   
Filmophile
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 05:25 PM






Walt, thanks for the help! This was a debate that certainly needed to
end. Also, can you give me the name of Brian Longs book? I'm always
interested in picking up new Porsche related literature.


Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old   
Filmophile
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 05:31 PM



I always thought the Omni was just a Chrysler badged version of the
Golf I. Anyone know much about it?

Also, if memory serves me, there was a Shelby version of the Omni with
a turbocharged engine that was unique to the model and a retuned
suspension. My understanding is that it was a hell of a car, at least
in terms of performance. I'm partial to the MKII 16 valve GTi though.


Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old   
Eisboch
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 06:03 PM




"Filmophile" <Filmophilia (AT) aol (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
I always thought the Omni was just a Chrysler badged version of the
Golf I. Anyone know much about it?

Also, if memory serves me, there was a Shelby version of the Omni with
a turbocharged engine that was unique to the model and a retuned
suspension. My understanding is that it was a hell of a car, at least
in terms of performance. I'm partial to the MKII 16 valve GTi though.

According to Wikipedia the Omni/Horizon was developed by Simca, the French
division of Chrysler Europe. Simca was bought by Peugeot which released
the car as the Talbot Horizon. Chrysler retained the US production rights.

From Wilipedia:

"The ultimate Dodge Omni was the Carroll Shelby-modified Omni GLH. 1984 was
the first year of the GLH, which carried over most of the modifications that
had been made the previous year to the Shelby Charger. 1985 was the debut of
the real Goes Like Hell model with the turbocharged Turbo I engine option.
The car carried over into 1986 unchanged and production was stopped. The
final 500 GLH cars were sold to Shelby, who used them as the basis for the
1986 Shelby GLHS."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_Omni

Eisboch




Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old   
Eisboch
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Omni to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 08:09 PM




"The Dead Senator" <deadsenator (AT) hotmail (DOT) com> wrote

Quote:
I realize this is subjective, but were any American cars attractive
betweeen, say...77 and the late 80s? I can't remember any off the top of
my head.
Well, if you didn't like the Omni or Horizon, you could always get an AMC
Pacer. :-)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMC_Pacer

Eisboch




Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old   
Devils944S2
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Omni to buy ... - 10-02-2006 , 11:31 PM



<I realize this is subjective, but were any American cars attractive
betweeen, say...77 and the late 80s? I can't remember any off the top of my
head.>

That is a tough one. The Corvette folks will say the C3 and C4, but the C3
was the last of the "classic" Vettes and was severly underpowered and the C4
was just bland. The Monte Carlo SS done right was not bad and I believe the
was the Grand National that looked pretty good. The 1980's were pretty
forgetable as far as the U.S. was concerned...I remember the big cars to
have were, the 944 of course, the 911SC, the 930, the Jaguar XJ12, the
Ferrari 308 (Magnum rules!)



Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old   
Walter Spector
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-03-2006 , 08:05 AM



Filmophile wrote:
Quote:
... can you give me the name of Brian Longs book? I'm always
interested in picking up new Porsche related literature.
Sure. It is simply called "Porsche 944". I bought my copy at the
Petersons Auto Museum in LA a few years ago, but now see that it is
available through Amazon (and no doubt, many others.)

Appended is a review I posted on rennlist back in 2002 on it.

Walt - 86 944 NA

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
The first 40 or so pages recount Porsche history from The Beginning,
up to and including the 924. The next 3 chapters cover the 944 development,
early production, and turbos. Finally a chapter on the 'twilight'
years - discussing the S2 and cab, and a few pages on the 968. It then
concludes with a few pages on buying and restoration, and some
production numbers. There are 190 pages in total.

Beautiful photos throughout and very well researched. Especially
fun are the numerous reprints of a lot of ad copy from the era.
Long comes from a British background, so naturally the RHD and
British view shows - but in a pleasant and not overwhelming manner.
He seems to appreciate that most of the purchasers of the book will
be non-Brits, so does cover the U.S. and ROW models in a very
complete fashion.

Long also, correctly, notes throughout the ever increasing pricing -
which eventually pushed the 944 way above what the market could support
for a 4-cylinder auto. Remember that the original 924 cost around
$9000 USD, and the final 944 turbos and S2s were nearly $50k just 13
years later! (Still amazes me that Porsche could let that happen...)

IMO, Morgans book ("Original Porsche 924/944/968") seems a bit more
definitive with respect to the various options available in different
years. However Morgans book also has to divide itself more equitably
amongst the 924, 944, and 968.

I think the Morgan book is probably still the first choice. But Longs
book is a *very* close second. Many 944 owners may actually prefer the Long
book because of the single series emphasis. Certainly there are lots of
interesting photos in the Long book which do not appear in the Morgan book.
I guess one really needs to own both...

Long has also recently published a comparable book devoted to the 924.
I did not buy it, but again a 924 owner might prefer it over the Morgan
book and others, due to the single series emphasis.

Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old   
Filmophile
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Need your expert opinion on which Porsche to buy ... - 10-03-2006 , 07:07 PM



Quote:
Sure. It is simply called "Porsche 944". I bought my copy at the Petersons Auto Museum in LA a few years ago, but now see that it is available through Amazon (and no doubt, many others.)
I'm going to be at the Petersen next week, so I'll check there first,
but I often find that their store is a bit highly priced.

Several years ago they had a Porsche exhibit there with several
vehicles (including some incredible one-off vehicles) from the museum
in Sttutgart. I wish they'd bring it back.
Thanks again.



Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.