AutosTalk Forums  

Cold Air Intake

Saab Saab Automobiles Discussions (alt.autos.saab)


Discuss Cold Air Intake in the Saab forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
p digital
 
Posts: n/a

Default Cold Air Intake - 10-30-2006 , 11:26 AM






Does anyone know of a good cold air intake that I can purchase and
install easliy with out too much modification and that will actually
improve the speed of my already "fast"stock 1995 900se turbo five speed
coupe saab? (non convertible)

Also, with out upgrading my exhaust, (which is after market, yet stock)
am I wasting my money! I am tired of hearing my friend (who drives a
cobra) says it will improve my horse power and increase my speed!


Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Fred W
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 10-30-2006 , 12:08 PM






p digital wrote:
Quote:
Does anyone know of a good cold air intake that I can purchase and
install easliy with out too much modification and that will actually
improve the speed of my already "fast"stock 1995 900se turbo five speed
coupe saab? (non convertible)

Also, with out upgrading my exhaust, (which is after market, yet stock)
am I wasting my money! I am tired of hearing my friend (who drives a
cobra) says it will improve my horse power and increase my speed!

Cold Air Intakes are a waste of time and money. Your cobra driving
friend is a goof. You will not increase the engine power because the
engine is not limited by the intake flow. If you want more power there
is only one thing that you need to do: increase the boost.

--
-Fred W


Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Paul Halliday
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 10-30-2006 , 03:16 PM



in article 1162225585.589496.135720 (AT) k70g20...oglegroups.com, p digital
at phillipdye (AT) gmail (DOT) com wrote on 30/10/06 16:26:

Quote:
Does anyone know of a good cold air intake that I can purchase and
install easliy with out too much modification and that will actually
improve the speed of my already "fast"stock 1995 900se turbo five speed
coupe saab? (non convertible)
With a turbo car, any cold air is going to get very warm once it has gone
through the charger. To that end, a better intercooler is always going to be
a good purchase, but IIRC the NG900 has a pretty good intercooler anyway.
You could always look at putting a more open air filter into your intake and
perhaps ensure that air is ducted up towards it.

Quote:
Also, with out upgrading my exhaust, (which is after market, yet stock)
am I wasting my money! I am tired of hearing my friend (who drives a
cobra) says it will improve my horse power and increase my speed!
Doubtful! I'm not sure what the stock size is for the NG900, but the C900 is
2.25". 2.5" is good for around 300 BHP and 3" is for serious power nuts ...
Or people who want a noisy exhaust I think yours will be about 2.5". If
you do want to gain a little power in the exhaust, spend your money on a
free-flow catalyser, or "Sports cat". Maybe 5 BHP? I'm sure they'll quote 10
BHP, but I wouldn't be too swayed by that.

Increasing the boost is the way to more power. Reckon on 5 BHP per 1 PSI of
boost increase. You can get good software maps from Maptun for your ECU.
They're costly, but people do rate them.

Paul

1989 900 Turbo S
http://saab.go.dyndns.org/




Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old   
MH
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 10-30-2006 , 03:47 PM



Quote:
.... that will actually improve the speed
If you want more speed you need more power. For more power you need to burn more
fuel:
- increase displacement
- increase boost
- increase RPM

Anything else will only be marginal...

--
MH
'72 97 '77 96 '78 95 '79 96
'91 900i
'95 900SE


Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old   
Fred W
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 11-02-2006 , 02:32 PM



- Bob - wrote:

Quote:

I disagree somewhat. You left off "increase flow and effective charge"

First, the charge: the difference in boost as the outside temps change
from season to season by 30 degrees or so is fairly substantial and
measurable by the butt dyno. This crude testing demonstrates that due
to the exponential effect of the forced induction that a cold charge
makes a big difference vs a warm charge. So, a CAI will help with HP.
I fail to see how the boost would vary with temperature, considering
that the ECU can run the charge up as high as it can until it begins to
detonate. That would be the "hard limit" on boost. When you have that
musch intake pressure going on, it isn't going to make a diddly bit of
difference how free flowing the intake is UNTIL you reach massive flow
rates, at which point you could lose pressure due to the restriction.

I don't have any specs or scientific evidence, but considering how small
the engine displacemnet is, and how low rps these things spin, I still
say any cold air intake, or other fiddling with the intake to "improve
flow" would not net any tangible difference.

Y boost MV

--
-Fred W


Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old   
Colin Stamp
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 11-02-2006 , 04:45 PM



On Thu, 02 Nov 2006 14:32:51 -0500, Fred W
<Malt_Hound@*spam-me-not*yahoo.com> wrote:

Quote:
I fail to see how the boost would vary with temperature, considering
that the ECU can run the charge up as high as it can until it begins to
detonate. That would be the "hard limit" on boost. When you have that
musch intake pressure going on, it isn't going to make a diddly bit of
difference how free flowing the intake is UNTIL you reach massive flow
rates, at which point you could lose pressure due to the restriction.
I have to say, I disagree a bit here too. Like you say, the boost
*pressure* won't change, but if the air is cooler, then the mass will
be greater for the same pressure. I agree though, that any increase in
peak power due to just fitting a CAI will be pretty marginal.

Quote:
I don't have any specs or scientific evidence, but considering how small
the engine displacemnet is, and how low rps these things spin, I still
say any cold air intake, or other fiddling with the intake to "improve
flow" would not net any tangible difference.
If you can do something to the intake that genuinely increases flow,
then it's still worthwhile, even though the boost pressure is limited.
It might not increase peak power, but IME, it really can help
off-boost where the boost limit doesn't apply.

I've got no figures, but I recently changed my air filter for a new
standard one. The old one had done 60K miles. My bum tells me that the
9-3 is now slightly faster off boost, has a slightly lower boost
threshold and shows a bit less lag. It could all be in my mind, I
suppose...

Cheers,

Colin.


Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old   
Fred W
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 11-03-2006 , 07:42 AM



- Bob - wrote:
Quote:
On Thu, 02 Nov 2006 21:45:28 +0000, Colin Stamp
col.dustbin (AT) stamp (DOT) plus.com> wrote:


I have to say, I disagree a bit here too. Like you say, the boost
*pressure* won't change, but if the air is cooler, then the mass will
be greater for the same pressure.


Yes... exactly. I have some semi-scientific testing done. I use an MBC
on my engine. Using an MBC eliminates the computer's ability to adjust
boost (the very intent). However, the computer still maintains final
authority and if it detects "too much" boost, it will cut the fuel, a
rather radical, but effective way, to prevent overboost as set by the
factory.

I have the MBC set up to run well in the Summer. It boosts very nicely
into the red and holds there - but never hits fuel cut. Recently temps
dropped around here, by about 30 degrees average over Summer. First, I
do notice a substantial increase in power, both seat of the pants as
well as watching the boost gauge. In addition, I managed to hit boost
cut accidentally the other day. I was not running WOT, just
accelerating hard. Still, I hit it. So, how much of an effective boost
increase do I get? One lb? Two? I don't know... but I know it's there,
no question about it, and it's reliably detectable with the
temperature change from the seasons.
OK, so you're saying that in the cooler weather, your manual boost
control allows higher boost pressure which results in more power? Well,
wasn't that my whole point all along? Yes, in a normally aspirated
engine colder (denser) air results in more power. But we aren't talking
about NA engines here... I said the way to increased power is increased
boost all along. I was just advocating doing it with an improved
software map in the APC (Automatic Performance Control) instead of a MBC
and colder temps.

The bigger advantage to sticking with an APC being that the APC can back
down the performance marginally if / when you have to run lower octane
fuel or as weather conditions & altitude vary. It does that by
monitoring the ignition performance through the direct ignition
cassette. In that way, with the right software, you can run the boost
right up to the point of preignition. With a MBC you need to leave some
margin so you don't get detonation, or risk blowing the engine.

But I'm not saying the stock APC program will do all of that. Just that
the potential is there with remapped software.


--
-Fred W


Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old   
darthpup
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Cold Air Intake - 11-04-2006 , 08:39 AM



Install water injection


Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.