![]() | |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
#11
| |||
| |||
|
|
On Tue, 01 Nov 2005 01:58:39 GMT, "TenPercent" tenpercent (AT) not-real-address (DOT) com> wrote: It just amazes me that you can buy a car for $15,000 like the Corolla and it will have a better long-term "JD Power" mechanical dependability rating after 5 years than a car that costs a whole lot more like a Mercedes, Cadillac, or Jaguar. Am I interpreting the JD Power surveys wrongly? For example, the '97 Corolla gets 4 stars in the JD Power survey for mechanical dependability compared to just 3 stars for a '97 S-Class Mercedes. My '92 Corolla Wagon just keeps rollin along... -- Scott in Florida Still Voting Democratic? You are Stuck On Stupid! |
#12
| |||
| |||
|
|
Anyone know why JD Powers doesn't include surveys of Rolls Royce, Ferrari, and Lotus owners in their automobile rankings? They include Lexus, Jag, and Mercedes owners. |
#13
| |||
| |||
|
|
"TenPercent" <tenpercent (AT) not-real-address (DOT) com> wrote in message news:jZz9f.282$Nd.108115 (AT) newshog (DOT) newsread.com... It just amazes me that you can buy a car for $15,000 like the Corolla and it will have a better long-term "JD Power" mechanical dependability rating after 5 years than a car that costs a whole lot more like a Mercedes, Cadillac, or Jaguar. Am I interpreting the JD Power surveys wrongly? But what are they actually surveying? How reliable is the survey? Isn't there a lot more to go wrong with a Mercedes than a Corolla? Are Mercedes owner more or less likely to report problems that Toyota owners? Most of these surveys depend on people deciding what is serious - do Toyota and Mercedes owners have the same opinion of what is serious? My sister will tell you her Honda has never had a problem - except I know the drivers side visor just fell of, the muffler has been replaced twice, the plug wires failed, paint is falling off the bumpers, and wheel covers, etc. However, if JD Powers surveyed my sister, Honda would look pretty damn good. If they asked me, they would look pretty bad (I would claim at least 5 problems, she would claim none). From what I've seen Toyota owners will put up with a lot more crap than Mercedes owners. Isn't it possible this skews the results? For example, the '97 Corolla gets 4 stars in the JD Power survey for mechanical dependability compared to just 3 stars for a '97 S-Class Mercedes. I am not sure where JD Powers is getting the data to determine the stars. I am assuming that it is coming from past results of the Vehicle Dependability Study. The 2005 version of this study is on line at http://www.jdpa.com/news/releases/pr...05089&search=1 . Take a look at this. Doesn't it make you wonder about the significance of their data collection when Buick, Lincoln, and Cadillac all out scored Toyota? Or that Mercury scored significantly higher than Ford and Buick scored way higher than Pontiac? Do you really think the survey is good enough to be significant to the level that you can say that Toyota with an average of 1.94 problem per vehicle is really better than Ford that has an average of 2.31 problems per vehicle? Especially when Mercury had 1.95 problems per vehicle? Looks to me, given all the possible sources of error, there is not much difference between any of the major brands. And certainly, a Toyota is not worth thousands more because you might have 0.37 fewer problems than a Ford. But if you do think this, why wouldn't you buy a Buick, which averages, according to this survey, only 1.63 problems per car. Prior year surveys are available at: http://www.jdpa.com/news/releases/pr...04055&search=1 http://www.jdpa.com/news/releases/pr...03050&search=1 http://www.jdpa.com/news/releases/pr...02141&search=1 http://www.jdpa.com/news/releases/pr...=2074&search=1 The differences are too small to be significant, and certainly not a reasons to buy a Toyota if you like one of the other brands better for other reasons (style, features, cost, etc.). Now if you just want to prove how smart you are for buying a Toyota instead of a Mercedes, I won't argue with you. Ed |
#14
| |||
| |||
|
|
If you look at J DO POWERS results is percentages, rather than as lists from top to bottom as they present their surveys, you will see the ALL have problems and they are ALL within the same percentages clustered around 2%. J D POWERS are designed so that every manufacture can point to them as a sales tool. What manufacture would pay their subscription rate is they could not use something from the surveys? They best and only true survey is sales numbers. More buyer believe the Camry is the best mid size sedan for the price, that is why it is number one. The same reason the Ford F150 is the number one vehicle, total sales and why GM make the best cars and trucks, since they sell more than any other manufacture. As well as why Wal-Mart is the number one retailer in the world, sales. YOU may prefer a particular retailer buy more buyer prefer Wal-Mart obviously mike hunt |
#15
| |||
| |||
|
|
Actually Mercedes never built reliable cars. In the late 70's a doctor friend once told me that the 2 greatest days in the life of a doctor is when he gets his first Mercedes, and when he trades it in. |
#16
| |||
| |||
|
|
TenPercent wrote: For example, the '97 Corolla gets 4 stars in the JD Power survey for mechanical dependability compared to just 3 stars for a '97 S-Class Mercedes. That's correct. The Germans just don't build cars like they used to. :-( |
#17
| |||
| |||
|
|
"Art" <begunaNOSPAMPLEASE (AT) mindspring (DOT) com> wrote in message news _M9f.4244$AS6.2900 (AT) newsread3 (DOT) news.atl.earthlink.net...Actually Mercedes never built reliable cars. In the late 70's a doctor friend once told me that the 2 greatest days in the life of a doctor is when he gets his first Mercedes, and when he trades it in. And yet used Mercedes always seem to have great resale value. Makes you wonder about the rationality of car buyers doesn't it..... Ed |
#18
| |||
| |||
|
|
"Mike Hunter" <mikehunt2 (AT) mailcity (DOT) com> wrote in message news:RdWdncjta_3CW_reUSdV9g (AT) ptd (DOT) net... If you look at J DO POWERS results is percentages, rather than as lists from top to bottom as they present their surveys, you will see the ALL have problems and they are ALL within the same percentages clustered around 2%. J D POWERS are designed so that every manufacture can point to them as a sales tool. What manufacture would pay their subscription rate is they could not use something from the surveys? They best and only true survey is sales numbers. More buyer believe the Camry is the best mid size sedan for the price, that is why it is number one. The same reason the Ford F150 is the number one vehicle, total sales and why GM make the best cars and trucks, since they sell more than any other manufacture. As well as why Wal-Mart is the number one retailer in the world, sales. YOU may prefer a particular retailer buy more buyer prefer Wal-Mart obviously mike hunt Mike, your spin assumes buyers have good information and make purchasing decisions for rational reasons. Reliability is only one factor people use when purchasing a vehicle. It might be that F150s have terrible reliability, but because of price, style, features, etc people are willing to buy them despite poor reliability (and no, I don't think F150s are unreliable, I am just using it as an example). And what about brand loyalty? Last year was the first time in my life, my Father actually considered buying something other than a Ford (he ended up in a Ford anyhow). I know lots of people that only shop for their pet brand of cars. I know more than few people who are only willing to look at Toyotas. Also, you are totally ignoring the effects of advertising. Advertising must work, otherwise companies would not spend so much on it. I am so tired of car ads, I almost can't watch TV. In case you missed it, it is Ford Toyotathon Truck Drive to be Number One Moving Forward Switch Month again......and again....... |
#19
| |||
| |||
|
|
So that is why the Camry is the number one selling mid size sedan in the US . ![]() |
#20
| |||
| |||
|
|
Actually Mercedes never built reliable cars. In the late 70's a doctor friend once told me that the 2 greatest days in the life of a doctor is when he gets his first Mercedes, and when he trades it in. "High Tech Misfit" <me (AT) privacy (DOT) net> wrote in message news:1y1jkfcroc8hg.dlg (AT) hightech (DOT) misfit... TenPercent wrote: It just amazes me that you can buy a car for $15,000 like the Corolla and it will have a better long-term "JD Power" mechanical dependability rating after 5 years than a car that costs a whole lot more like a Mercedes, Cadillac, or Jaguar. Am I interpreting the JD Power surveys wrongly? For example, the '97 Corolla gets 4 stars in the JD Power survey for mechanical dependability compared to just 3 stars for a '97 S-Class Mercedes. That's correct. The Germans just don't build cars like they used to. :-( |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
| |